Is Deckers' Pain Nike's Gain? 1 Wall Street Analyst Thinks So.

Company Performance - Deckers' stock fell after reporting fiscal fourth-quarter results that exceeded expectations but provided disappointing guidance [1] - The company achieved a 6.5% year-over-year revenue increase to $1.02 billion, with Ugg brand sales growing by 3.6$4.99 billion, with Ugg sales up 13.1% and Hoka up 23.6% [2] Future Guidance - Management refrained from providing full-year guidance due to macroeconomic uncertainties, projecting a 9% revenue growth for fiscal 2026's first quarter [3] - Earnings per share are expected to decline due to rising costs from tariffs, freight, and increased promotional activities [3] Market Position - Deckers has gained market share from Nike, with a compound annual revenue growth rate of 19% over the last five years [4] - Hoka's revenue reached $2.23 billion in fiscal 2025, while Ugg's sales were$2.53 billion, indicating Hoka's strong position in the running category [4] Competitor Analysis - Nike has experienced a decline in revenue for several quarters, missing out on a post-pandemic boom in running [6] - However, Nike's sales in the running category grew by a mid-single-digit percentage in fiscal 2025 Q3, indicating a potential recovery [7][8] - Hoka's 10% revenue growth suggests it is still gaining market share from Nike, but analysts believe Nike may be regaining ground [9][10] Analyst Insights - Jefferies analyst Randal Konik suggests that Hoka's slowing growth may indicate a shift in market share back to Nike [10] - Jefferies has given Nike a buy rating with a price target of $115, which is approximately 85% higher than its current level [11] - Nike is currently trading at its lowest enterprise-value-to-sales multiple in 15 years, primarily due to a decline in stock price [12]