Workflow
钓友突发疾病死亡,同行者是否担责?
Ren Min Wang·2025-06-11 08:18

Core Viewpoint - The court ruled that the defendants, who were fishing companions, did not commit any tortious act and should not bear compensation liability, dismissing all claims from the plaintiff [3][4]. Group 1: Incident Overview - The incident involved three individuals, Zhang Xiaowei, Peng Jun, and Liu Zheng, who went fishing together at Changshou Lake in Chongqing [2]. - Zhang Xiaowei experienced sudden health issues, leading to his death from a myocardial infarction, despite attempts by his companions to assist him [2][3]. Group 2: Court's Reasoning - The court determined that the fishing activity was spontaneous and informal, lacking any organized structure or management, thus the defendants were not considered organizers of the event [3]. - The court found that the companions fulfilled their reasonable duty of care, as the rapid onset of Zhang's condition exceeded what could be reasonably anticipated by the defendants [3]. Group 3: Legal Implications - The ruling emphasized that the mutual assistance obligations among friends in casual social activities should not be overextended, distinguishing them from formal public venues with defined safety responsibilities [4]. - The court highlighted that the defendants were not professional medical personnel and their actions were consistent with common sense and reasonable expectations in such situations [4].