华为盘古大模型事件的“三重门”

Core Viewpoint - A research report by GitHub user HonestAGI claims a high similarity of 0.927 between Huawei's Pangu Pro MoE 72B model and Alibaba's Qwen-2.5 14B model, suggesting potential incremental training rather than complete independent development [2][3] Group 1: Similarity Claims and Methodology - The report indicates that the similarity between the two models is statistically significant, exceeding the typical threshold of 0.7, raising concerns about the originality of Huawei's model [2] - Critics argue that the methodology used by HonestAGI is overly simplistic and lacks comprehensive benchmarking, with some suggesting potential cherry-picking of data [2][3][4] - The identity and credibility of the HonestAGI team have been questioned, as they lack verifiable academic credentials and their report has been removed from GitHub [5][6] Group 2: Copyright and Compliance Issues - The presence of Alibaba's copyright notice in the Pangu model's code has sparked discussions about compliance and the authenticity of claims regarding the model's originality [8] - Industry experts emphasize the importance of clear attribution in model development, particularly when using existing open-source models for further training [8][9] - Huawei's Noah's Ark Lab has stated that the Pangu model was developed based on their own hardware and practices, adhering to open-source licensing requirements [9] Group 3: Organizational Changes and Internal Dynamics - Anonymous letters from purported employees of Huawei's Noah's Ark Lab have surfaced, discussing internal team changes and raising allegations of improper practices in model training and development [10][11] - The letters claim that there have been significant personnel changes within the lab, with implications for the integrity of the Pangu model's development process [10][11][12] - The current director of the lab, Wang Yunhe, has been mentioned in the context of these allegations, with no official response from Huawei regarding the claims made in the anonymous letters [11][12][14]