山姆讲不好中产故事了

Core Insights - The incident involving the brief appearance and subsequent removal of the "Haoliyou Pie" at Sam's Club highlights a significant trust issue with the middle-class consumer base in China [4][21][24] - The core of the controversy is not merely about the product itself but rather the deeper social narrative surrounding middle-class values and aesthetic standards [4][5][21] Group 1: Trust Dynamics - Sam's Club operates on a membership model that relies on long-term trust and a carefully curated selection of products [14][18] - The trust established by Sam's Club is built over time through strict product selection, scale procurement, and a robust supply chain [15][16][18] - Any deviation from the established aesthetic and quality standards can lead to significant backlash from the middle-class consumers, as seen in the "Haoliyou incident" [22][23][24] Group 2: Market Positioning - Sam's Club has been positioned in the second quadrant of a trust-efficiency matrix, aiming to expand into the first quadrant [12][30] - The company faces challenges in balancing efficiency-driven expansion with maintaining the curated experience that its members expect [31][32] - Competitors like Hema and other traditional supermarkets are not only competing on product selection but also on immediate service delivery, which poses a threat to Sam's Club's unique value proposition [34][35][38] Group 3: Social Media Impact - Social media has transformed consumer-brand relationships, amplifying any perceived missteps and turning them into collective narratives [25][27][28] - The rapid dissemination of information on platforms like Xiaohongshu can quickly escalate minor issues into significant trust crises for brands like Sam's Club [27][28] - The "Haoliyou incident" serves as a reminder of the fragility of brand trust in the current media landscape, where consumer sentiment can shift rapidly [28][42]