启迪药业高溢价收购合理性存疑 投服中心呼吁中小股东积极行权

Core Viewpoint - Qidi Pharmaceutical plans to acquire 55% of Wuhan Mingshi Pharmaceutical for 141.35 million yuan, facing opposition from three directors due to concerns over the target company's weak core competitiveness and high acquisition price [1][2]. Group 1: Target Company Overview - The target company specializes in the research, production, and sales of traditional Chinese medicine and health food, holding three Chinese medicine approvals and 13 health food registrations [2]. - The net profits for the target company were 13.14 million yuan in 2022 and 13.42 million yuan from January to August 2023 [2]. Group 2: Concerns from Directors and Analysts - Three out of seven directors, including the vice chairman and an independent director, voted against the acquisition, citing the target company's lack of flagship products and weak core competitiveness [2]. - The target company's valuation of 260 million yuan represents a 400.72% increase, which analysts believe does not align with its core competitiveness [2][3]. Group 3: Performance Commitments and Industry Challenges - The target company has made performance commitments for net profits of no less than 22 million yuan, 25.3 million yuan, and 26.4 million yuan from 2024 to 2026, which represents an 87% increase compared to its 2022 net profit [2]. - Analysts express skepticism about the target company's ability to meet these commitments due to declining product prices, a slowdown in the health food industry, and rising raw material costs [3]. Group 4: Risks Associated with the Acquisition - The acquisition announcement did not adequately disclose potential risks, including the risk of performance commitment failure, as the commitment is backed by two individual shareholders without sufficient guarantees [4]. - There is a risk of goodwill impairment due to the high acquisition price compared to the target company's book value, which could impact the acquirer's financial health [4]. - The acquirer's current financial situation raises concerns about its ability to support the acquisition cost and other ongoing investments, with a reported cash flow deficit and declining profitability [5].