有人建议，取消外卖，关闭电商，恢复人间烟火气和市面繁荣，你同意吗？

Group 1 - The core issue is the struggle of physical retail businesses in the post-pandemic era, with many restaurants and shops facing reduced customer traffic and some closing down [1][3] - A growing debate has emerged around the idea of stopping food delivery and e-commerce to revive physical stores, highlighting the complexity of the issue which affects millions of livelihoods and daily lives [3][10] - The existence of food delivery services has become a necessity for many, with 520 million users in China, predominantly young professionals who rely on it to balance work and life [4][6] Group 2 - E-commerce has transformed daily life, with over 100 million users aged 60 and above, and 72% of them finding online shopping significantly convenient [6][7] - The price advantage of e-commerce over physical stores is notable, with some products being 30% cheaper online, which is crucial for families facing rising living costs [7][14] - The delivery and e-commerce sectors employ over 150 million people, making them a vital part of the economy and a significant source of income for many families [8][9] Group 3 - Many physical stores view food delivery and e-commerce as lifelines rather than competitors, with 82% of surviving restaurants offering delivery services [13][14] - The real challenges for physical retail include shrinking consumer demand, intense competition, and rising operational costs, which are exacerbated by the presence of delivery and e-commerce [14][15] - Solutions for revitalizing physical retail include reducing operational costs, encouraging differentiated competition, and enhancing consumer experiences [16][17][18] Group 4 - The essence of a vibrant commercial atmosphere lies in the connections between people and the cultural fit of business models, rather than merely forcing consumers to shop in physical stores [16][18] - The evolution of commercial forms is inevitable, and the focus should be on creating new vitality in the market rather than longing for past shopping experiences [18]