TENCENT(HK:00700) Mei Ri Jing Ji Xin Wen·2025-08-15 00:46Core Viewpoint - The ongoing legal case involving Tencent's "Honor of Kings" game has sparked significant public interest, focusing on the demand for transparency regarding the game's matchmaking algorithm, which is claimed to influence player experience and retention [2][3][4]. Group 1: Legal Case Overview - The case is referred to as "China's first game algorithm case," with the plaintiff, a seasoned player and lawyer, seeking the public disclosure of the matchmaking algorithm used in "Honor of Kings" [2]. - The court hearings have concluded, but the judgment date remains uncertain, leading to widespread media attention and discussions on social platforms [2][3]. - The plaintiff argues that the game’s matchmaking system is unfair, alleging that it manipulates player win rates to enhance retention [4][5]. Group 2: Arguments from Both Sides - Tencent presented evidence during the hearings showing that player win rates do not align with the plaintiff's claim of a controlled 50% win rate, citing specific player statistics to support their position [3][4]. - The company contends that the matchmaking mechanism is a trade secret and that disclosing it could lead to unfair competition and exploitation by malicious players [5][8]. - The plaintiff emphasizes the need for algorithm transparency, arguing that the public has a right to understand the rules governing their gaming experience [5][6]. Group 3: Industry Implications - The case raises broader questions about algorithm regulation in the gaming industry, as there are currently no clear legal precedents requiring game companies to disclose their matchmaking algorithms [7]. - Tencent has previously denied any intentional manipulation of player matchups, asserting that the matchmaking system aims to create balanced and fair gaming experiences [7][8]. - The potential negative consequences of disclosing matchmaking algorithms, such as exploitation by malicious players and the impact on fair play, are significant concerns raised by Tencent [8].