Apple Inc: From Innovation Pioneer to Technological Stagnation

Core Viewpoint - Apple is facing criticism for perceived stagnation in innovation, with notable figures like Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg highlighting the company's reliance on past successes rather than introducing significant new technologies [1][2][5]. Group 1: Criticism of Innovation - Zuckerberg criticized Apple for not making breakthroughs since the introduction of the iPhone, claiming the company is "resting on its laurels" and imposing high App Store commissions [2][5]. - The launch of the iPhone 17 on September 9, 2025, led to a 3.2% drop in Apple's stock, erasing approximately US$100 billion in market capitalization due to minor updates and lack of AI advancements [5][6]. - iPhone market share in the U.S. decreased from 56% to 49%, while Samsung's share increased from 23% to 31%, indicating a shift in consumer preference towards competitors [6]. Group 2: Apple's Achievements and Market Position - Despite criticism, the iPhone 17 introduced features like a scratch-resistant ceramic screen and a larger battery, with third-quarter 2025 sales up 13% year-on-year [8][10]. - Apple has sold over 3 billion iPhones since 2007, and its ecosystem remains superior in integration, providing a seamless user experience [8][10]. - The company is investing in new markets, such as establishing the Apple Developer Academy in Indonesia with a US$160 million investment, indicating a commitment to local technology ecosystems [9]. Group 3: Financial Strength and Market Strategy - Apple's market valuation remains around US$3.48 trillion, making it one of the largest companies globally, despite the stock drop post-iPhone 17 launch [10]. - The company has maintained good relations with the government through a US$100 billion investment in the U.S., demonstrating resilience against external pressures like tariffs [10]. - Apple's focus on privacy and a closed ecosystem, while limiting AI innovation speed, is also seen as a strength in an era of data privacy concerns [11]. Group 4: Future Outlook - Allegations of stagnation have impacted investor confidence, but Apple has opportunities for recovery with plans for a foldable iPhone and a 20th-anniversary edition in 2027 [14]. - The company must balance its "quality over speed" philosophy with the need for radical innovation to meet high market expectations [15].