“轻喜”万金油，开始被嫌弃

Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding the drama "赴山海" (Journey to the Sea) is primarily due to the incorporation of "light comedy" elements, which are seen as incompatible with the original narrative style, leading to a negative overall viewing experience [2][3][5]. Group 1: Impact of Light Comedy - The introduction of light comedy in "赴山海" has been criticized for disrupting the original narrative rhythm and style, which is rooted in themes of chivalry and national duty during the Southern Song Dynasty [3][4]. - The light comedic elements have not enhanced the drama but rather diluted its martial arts essence, resulting in viewer backlash against the creative team's approach [5][6]. - The trend of light comedy in historical dramas has been prevalent since the success of "庆余年" (Joy of Life), which effectively blended modern humor with a historical setting [7][8]. Group 2: Market Trends and Audience Demand - The success of "庆余年" sparked a wave of light comedy adaptations in the drama market, with subsequent series like "赘婿" (The Son-in-Law) continuing this trend [9][10]. - Light comedy has become a ubiquitous element in various genres, appealing to a broad audience due to its accessibility and ability to provide entertainment amidst real-life pressures [12]. - However, the indiscriminate application of light comedy across all genres has raised concerns about its suitability and effectiveness, as not all narratives can accommodate such elements without losing their core essence [14][20]. Group 3: Creative Challenges - Successful integration of light comedy requires careful consideration of narrative pacing, thematic consistency, and character logic, which is often overlooked in recent adaptations [18][20]. - The failure to appropriately blend light comedic elements with the original story can lead to a loss of emotional depth and viewer engagement, as seen in "赴山海" and "折腰" (Bending Waist) [15][17]. - Even previously successful light comedies like "庆余年" faced criticism in their sequels for excessive comedic content that did not align with the overall narrative tone [19].