After Posting Another Solid Earnings Beat, Is Costco's Stock Due for a Rally?

Core Viewpoint - Costco continues to show strong resilience in a challenging economic environment, but its stock performance has been lackluster despite solid financial results [1][3]. Financial Performance - For fiscal Q4 2025, Costco reported revenue of $86.2 billion, slightly exceeding analyst expectations of $86.1 billion [5]. - Earnings per share (EPS) for the same period were $5.87, surpassing Wall Street estimates of $5.80 [5]. - Comparable sales growth for fiscal Q4 was 5.7%, with U.S. growth at 5.1% and international growth at 8.6% [6]. Market Position and Strategy - Costco's warehouse stores remain popular due to their value proposition for bulk buyers, and there is potential for further market expansion, particularly outside North America [2]. - The company is focusing on increasing its private-label Kirkland Signature brand offerings to provide alternatives to goods affected by tariffs, indicating adaptability to current macroeconomic conditions [7]. Stock Performance and Valuation - Despite strong earnings, Costco's stock fell a few percentage points, remaining flat for the year, contrasting with the S&P 500's 13% increase [8][9]. - The stock is currently trading at a price-to-earnings (P/E) multiple of over 50, significantly higher than the average S&P 500 stock's P/E of 25, raising concerns about its inflated valuation [10]. - High valuations and the impact of tariffs on consumer goods have led to investor concerns about potential slowing growth rates, leaving little margin for error in Costco's stock price [11]. Investment Outlook - While Costco may still be a good long-term investment, its current high valuation makes it less attractive compared to other reasonably priced growth stocks [12].