罗琳和艾玛，谁才是时间的朋友

Core Viewpoint - The ongoing conflict between J.K. Rowling and Emma Watson highlights the shifting dynamics of public opinion regarding gender identity and the implications for their respective roles in the "Harry Potter" franchise [3][6][10]. Group 1: Background of the Conflict - The dispute traces back to 2018 when Rowling made controversial comments about transgender individuals, leading to accusations of discrimination [14][15]. - Subsequent statements by Rowling in 2019 and 2020 further fueled the controversy, resulting in significant backlash from fans and former colleagues [18][23]. - The "cancellation" of Rowling from the "Harry Potter" community culminated in her exclusion from the 20th-anniversary special program, despite her claims of voluntarily declining to participate [30][32]. Group 2: Current Developments - Recently, Emma Watson attempted to address the rift during a podcast, but Rowling publicly rejected any reconciliation [5][11]. - The narrative has shifted, with Rowling regaining some public support as the discourse around gender identity evolves, particularly following a recent UK court ruling affirming the legal definition of women based on biological sex [73][74]. - The decline of the DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) movement has also contributed to a changing landscape, with Rowling's views gaining traction as political correctness wanes [79][80]. Group 3: Public Perception and Future Implications - Watson faces criticism for perceived inconsistency in her stance, while Rowling's steadfastness on her views has led to a resurgence of support [70][71]. - The situation illustrates the complexities of navigating public opinion in the context of evolving social norms, with Rowling's past as a progressive voice now being challenged by newer interpretations of gender identity [96][99]. - The ongoing discourse raises questions about the future of the "Harry Potter" franchise and the potential for new adaptations under Rowling's creative control [10][96].