Workflow
X lawsuit vs. Apple and Open AI stays in Fort Worth, Texas; judge suggests they move there
AppleApple(US:AAPL) CNBCยท2025-10-19 21:27

Core Viewpoint - A federal judge has ruled that the lawsuit filed by X and xAI against Apple and OpenAI regarding alleged monopolistic practices in the artificial intelligence market will remain in the Fort Worth, Texas federal court, despite minimal connections to the area [1][6]. Group 1: Lawsuit Details - The lawsuit accuses Apple and OpenAI of maintaining monopolies in the AI market, with specific allegations that Apple favors OpenAI's ChatGPT in App Store rankings while deprioritizing competitors like xAI's Grok [9][10]. - The judge, Mark Pittman, highlighted the lack of strong connections between the companies and Fort Worth, noting that X Corp. is based in Bastrop, Texas, and both Apple and OpenAI are headquartered in California [4][6]. Group 2: Judicial Commentary - Judge Pittman criticized the practice of forum-shopping, where plaintiffs choose specific jurisdictions to increase their chances of favorable rulings, and he encouraged the companies to consider relocating their headquarters to Fort Worth [2][5]. - He pointed out that the Fort Worth division's docket is significantly busier than that of the Dallas division, which has more judges, indicating a potential bias in the judicial process [3][6]. Group 3: Venue Decision - Despite the minimal connections to Fort Worth, the judge decided to keep the case there, stating that the defendants did not file a motion to transfer venue, which influenced his decision [6][7]. - The U.S. 5th Circuit Court of Appeals has raised the standard for transferring venue, making it more challenging for cases to be moved to different jurisdictions [8].