高连奎评《货币、金融、现实与道德》｜债务奴役：利息沦为现代化的贡品？

Core Argument - The book "Money, Finance, Reality, and Morality" by Edward Hadas presents a unique perspective on economics, viewing money and finance as profound moral and social phenomena, prompting a reevaluation of the relationship between economics and morality [2][23]. Group 1: Concept of "Post-Noble Finance" - Hadas introduces the concept of "post-noble finance," categorizing financing into economic financing, aimed at economic development, and social financing, which resembles a form of tribute from one class to another [3][6]. - The book critiques "post-noble finance" for perpetuating a system where wealth is transferred from poorer members of society to wealthier financial investors, creating long-term monetary obligations from the poor to the rich [6][7]. Group 2: Historical Context and Mechanisms - The emergence of money complicated the "great exchange" era, where barter was the norm, leading to a pursuit of money as a primary motivation due to its saving function [4][6]. - Hadas discusses a "triad" concept of money, linking it to Keynes' theory of the three motives for holding money, which helps clarify the book's complex ideas [4][6]. Group 3: Critique of Economic Efficiency - "Post-noble finance" is criticized for not being designed to enhance economic efficiency but rather to maintain the privileges of a capitalist elite, undermining egalitarian norms in contemporary society [7][8]. - The book highlights how modern rent payments and government debt repayments reflect a flow of funds from the poor to the rich, similar to historical tribute systems [7][8]. Group 4: The Role of Greed - Greed is identified as a driving force behind the commitment of the relatively wealthy to "post-noble finance," leading to a societal structure where the rich benefit at the expense of the poor [9][10]. - Hadas argues that the academic community has largely ignored the concept of greed, which has contributed to the normalization of financial misconduct and the erosion of moral distinctions in economics [10][11]. Group 5: Implications for Economic Policy - The book suggests that the cyclical nature of greed correlates with monetary policy, proposing that optimal central bank interest rates could mitigate systemic financial greed [21][22]. - Hadas emphasizes the need for a moral foundation in economics, arguing that the lack of ethical constraints on greed has led to frequent economic crises and social inequality [15][16].