年费680元买个寂寞，山姆强推流量玩法遭抵制，会员制初心哪去了

Core Viewpoint - The recent update of the Sam's Club app has led to a significant backlash from members, highlighting a crisis of trust in the membership model due to perceived declines in product transparency and user experience [1][3][4] User Experience Issues - The app update, which began testing in late August, resulted in complaints about overly beautified product images and hidden ingredient lists, leading to a loss of the "what you see is what you get" principle [4][7] - Users reported that product details became more complicated to access, with essential information being hidden behind multiple clicks, increasing decision-making costs [4][7] - Concerns about information transparency arose, with discrepancies between product descriptions and actual labels, such as "domestic" versus "imported" [4][7] Strategic Conflicts - The backlash reflects deeper strategic conflicts within Sam's Club, as the new management attempts to apply e-commerce traffic strategies to a membership-based model, which fundamentally relies on trust rather than traffic [7][9] - The membership fee structure, which is designed to attract high-spending customers, is being undermined by a shift towards a more transactional, traffic-driven approach [7][9] Identity Crisis and Management Changes - The app update failure is symptomatic of a broader identity crisis as Sam's Club undergoes strategic transformation, marked by a management change with the appointment of a new president from Alibaba [9][10] - Rapid expansion has put pressure on supply chains and operational efficiency, with membership growth slowing from 40% to 16% [10][12] Trust and Quality Concerns - Past incidents of perceived product quality degradation, such as the introduction of lower-quality brands, have exacerbated the current trust crisis among members [12][14] - The company has acknowledged the need to improve and has begun to replace some product images with real photos, but these incremental changes may not be sufficient to quell member dissatisfaction [14][16] Lessons for Membership Retail - The situation serves as a cautionary tale for membership-based retail, emphasizing that digital transformation must prioritize member trust and experience over mere data metrics [16][17] - Sam's Club faces a critical juncture, needing to redefine the unique value proposition of its membership fees amidst growing member discontent [17]