刚刚，中美机器人爆发了一场论战

Core Viewpoint - A video showcasing a humanoid robot from a Chinese startup, MindOn Tech, has sparked a global debate regarding its authenticity, with claims of "no acceleration, no remote control" being challenged by skeptics in the U.S. [1][4][10] Group 1: Video and Technology - The video features a humanoid robot performing tasks such as watering plants, throwing garbage, and playing with children, demonstrating impressive fluidity in its movements [2][4] - MindOn Tech claims that the robot operates autonomously without any external control, which has led to significant interest and skepticism [4][10] Group 2: Skepticism and Responses - Brett Adcock, CEO of Figure AI, expressed doubts about the video's authenticity, suggesting it may involve pre-recorded movements without real-time perception [5][7] - Adcock has previously criticized another Chinese robotics company, UBTECH, for allegedly using computer-generated imagery in their demonstrations [8][10] Group 3: Support for Authenticity - Supporters of MindOn Tech have provided backup footage to validate the video's claims, arguing that the robot's actions are feasible based on existing academic research [11][15] - Mike Kalil, a U.S. tech blogger, argues that the robot's capabilities are a result of integrating advanced research in imitation and reinforcement learning, indicating a significant engineering achievement [15] Group 4: Implications for the Industry - If MindOn Tech's software can deliver genuine functionality on cost-effective hardware like Unitree's G1, it could pose a serious threat to established players like Figure AI, 1X Technologies, and Tesla [17][18] - The current trend among U.S. companies focuses on vertical integration, developing both the AI software and the hardware, which may be challenged by MindOn Tech's approach [18][19] Group 5: Potential Market Shift - MindOn Tech's model suggests a decoupling of AI software and hardware, akin to the "Android model," which could disrupt the competitive landscape of humanoid robotics [19][20] - The competition may shift from hardware capabilities to the intelligence of the AI, potentially leading to a more open and flexible market environment [20][21] - This debate over the video's authenticity reflects a broader clash of technological approaches and business models, indicating a significant shift in the robotics industry [21]