Starbucks Stock: Why $65 Isn't Impossible

Core Insights - Starbucks stock has underperformed in 2025, declining by 14% compared to a 14% gain in the S&P 500, raising questions about the reasons behind this downturn [2][3] Labor Strain - Ongoing labor disturbances in the U.S. are causing strain, with baristas organizing walkouts over wages and contract negotiations, leading to concerns about increased labor costs and store disruptions [5] Valuation Concerns - The market assigns a premium valuation to Starbucks, but fundamentals do not support this, as earnings and cash flow lag behind the multiples investors are paying [6] Growth Trends - Starbucks has seen a significant decline in growth, with an average annual revenue growth of under 5% over the past three years, and only a 2.8% increase in sales over the last twelve months [7] Profitability Metrics - Starbucks' operating margin is around 10% and net margin is approximately 7%, which are below market averages, indicating insufficient profitability to justify its premium valuation [8] Financial Stability - Starbucks has a solid financial base with about $3.5 billion in cash and $16 billion in total debt, making its balance sheet manageable relative to its $96 billion market cap [10] Downturn Performance - Historically, Starbucks stock has experienced sharper declines and slower recoveries during crises, such as a 44% drop during the 2022 inflation shock compared to a 25% decline in the S&P 500 [11] Investment Outlook - Current analysis suggests that Starbucks appears unattractive at its current prices due to misalignment between high valuation and weak operational performance [13]