没考上可退费？“考公”培训靠谱吗？

Core Viewpoint - The increasing popularity of civil service exam preparation ("考公") among college graduates has led to a surge in various training programs, raising concerns about their effectiveness and legitimacy [1][2][3]. Group 1: Training Programs and Costs - Many students are investing in civil service exam training, with costs for interview training programs reaching up to 9,800 yuan for an 8-day course, and 23,800 yuan for a "guarantee course" that offers partial refunds if the student fails [2]. - Training programs vary in price based on location and exam type, with small group classes typically costing around 10,000 yuan per week, while one-on-one tutoring can exceed this amount [2]. - The quality and legitimacy of these training programs are inconsistent, with some institutions operating without the necessary educational licenses, which raises concerns about regulatory compliance [2][3]. Group 2: Refund Policies and Student Experiences - Some training institutions promise full support and refunds if students do not pass the exam, but many students report difficulties in obtaining refunds, with delays and unresponsive staff being common issues [3]. - Students express mixed feelings about the effectiveness of these training programs, with some believing they provide valuable insights into exam formats, while others feel they may lead to overly formulaic responses [3]. Group 3: Alternatives and Recommendations - Students often prefer commercial training programs over university career services, citing a lack of practical job-seeking skills offered by their schools [4]. - Experts recommend that students be cautious of contract pitfalls and misleading advertisements when selecting training programs, and suggest attending trial classes to assess the quality of instruction [4]. - There is a call for improved public employment services and better integration of career guidance within universities to reduce reliance on commercial training services [4][5].