三亚西岛景区被指“拍摄垄断”，关键是规则要透明

Core Viewpoint - The incident at Sanya West Island highlights the ongoing conflict between tourists' rights to choose their photography services and the scenic area's monopolistic practices regarding commercial photography [1][2][3] Group 1: Incident Overview - A photographer was fined 50 yuan for providing commercial photography services to tourists at Sanya West Island, as the scenic area only allows its own photographers [1] - The situation escalated into a dispute involving local enforcement, indicating that unauthorized commercial photography is subject to administrative penalties [1] Group 2: Consumer Rights and Regulations - Tourists have the right to choose their service providers, raising questions about whether they can bring their own items, such as water, into the park [2] - The scenic area claims to have invested significantly in its development, which justifies its rules; however, these rules should be clear and communicated to visitors beforehand [2] Group 3: Historical Context and Ongoing Issues - This is not the first controversy for Sanya West Island; previous incidents include the establishment of a VIP photography area that was later removed following public backlash [3] - The ongoing disputes reflect a broader issue of resource management and the balance between monopolistic practices and consumer rights within the tourism industry [3]