“特朗普”级战列舰计划是闹剧一场？专家辣评：永不启航的纸老虎

Core Viewpoint - The announcement of the "Trump-class" battleship by President Trump claims it will be the "fastest, largest, and most powerful" battleship, but experts argue that battleships are outdated and the project faces significant challenges [1][2]. Group 1: Project Overview - The "Trump-class" battleship is described as a super warship that aims to maintain U.S. military dominance and intimidate adversaries [1]. - The last U.S. battleship was built over 80 years ago, and the last Iowa-class battleships were retired nearly 30 years ago, indicating that the concept of battleships is outdated [1][2]. Group 2: Expert Opinions - Mark Cancian from CSIS believes the project is impractical due to its long design cycle, high costs, and misalignment with the Navy's current distributed firepower strategy [1][5]. - Bernard Loo compares the project to Japan's Yamato and Musashi battleships, suggesting it is more about prestige than practical military utility [2]. Group 3: Design and Functionality - The proposed battleship will have a displacement of over 35,000 tons and a length exceeding 840 feet, which could make it a target for enemy forces [2]. - Bryan Clark emphasizes that the effectiveness of a vessel relies more on its weaponry than its classification, noting that the Trump-class will include advanced weapon systems like electromagnetic railguns and laser weapons [4]. Group 4: Cost and Budget Implications - The estimated cost of the Trump-class battleship could exceed $8 billion, making it 2 to 3 times more expensive than current destroyers, which could strain the Navy's budget [6]. - Historical context shows that U.S. weapon projects often exceed their budgets and timelines, as seen with the Zumwalt-class destroyer, which was reduced from 32 to 3 units due to cost overruns [6].