下一只黑天鹅，关税退款“大赌局”！

Core Viewpoint - A potential legal battle may force the U.S. government to refund hundreds of billions in tariffs, creating a unique speculative market around this issue [3][4]. Group 1: Legal Context and Implications - U.S. Treasury Secretary Yellen acknowledged that if the Supreme Court rules certain tariffs imposed by the Trump administration as illegal, the Treasury may have to refund "about half of the tariffs," which he described as a "terrible" blow to the department [3][4]. - Two lower courts have already ruled that the Trump administration lacked legal authority to impose certain tariffs under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, with the case now set for oral arguments at the Supreme Court on November 5 [4][12]. - As of August this year, over $70 billion in disputed tariffs have been collected, and a reversal of this policy could have profound effects on U.S. finances and importing businesses [4][12]. Group 2: Market Reactions and Investment Strategies - Wall Street investment banks, including Jefferies and Oppenheimer, are facilitating unique transactions connecting importers who have paid high tariffs with investors seeking high returns, primarily hedge funds [5]. - The core logic of these transactions involves cash-strapped importers selling their future potential claims for tariff refunds at a significant discount, allowing them to receive guaranteed payments without waiting for court decisions [5]. - Investors typically purchase these claims for 20 to 40 cents on the dollar, meaning favorable Supreme Court rulings could yield several times the original investment [5]. Group 3: Retail Investor Participation - Unlike institutional investors, retail investors are participating in this speculative market through emerging prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket, where they can place small bets on outcomes such as whether the Supreme Court will uphold the tariffs [7][8]. - The trading prices of contracts on these platforms reflect the market's implied probability of the tariffs being upheld, estimated at around 40% [8][10]. - However, the liquidity in these markets is low, with total trading volumes on Kalshi and Polymarket being less than $250,000 and $400,000 respectively, making them ineffective for large-scale risk hedging [10]. Group 4: Challenges Ahead - The outcome of all bets hinges on the Supreme Court's decision, which may be influenced not only by legal interpretations but also by the justices' views on executive power [12]. - Even if the Supreme Court rules the tariffs illegal, the refund process could be complicated, described as a "logistical nightmare," particularly for small importers who may struggle to provide detailed documentation for refunds [13][14].