仇保兴、李稻葵、朱宁激辩：稳楼市已到关键时刻，中央须出“大招”

Core Viewpoint - The stability of the real estate market is crucial for boosting consumption and ensuring the resilience of the overall economy, necessitating decisive and innovative government policies to reverse market expectations [2][3][5]. Group 1: Relationship Between Real Estate and Consumption - The relationship between real estate and consumption is clear; a household's consumption ability depends on its asset value and future income expectations. The current decline in consumption is due to the significant reduction in household assets and weakened confidence in future income caused by the downturn in the real estate market [3][5]. - Experts emphasize the need to stabilize asset values and market expectations to solidify the foundation of consumption, aligning with the central government's repeated calls for "stabilizing housing prices, land prices, and expectations" [5][6]. Group 2: Investment Attributes of Real Estate - Real estate possesses both consumption and investment attributes, similar to government bonds and stocks. The current rental yield in some declining markets is approaching 2%, making it relatively attractive compared to savings [6]. - The shift in market expectations has led to a decline in transaction volumes despite falling prices, contrasting with typical consumer behavior where price drops stimulate sales. This change is attributed to a generational shift in perception, particularly among younger individuals who no longer view rising property prices as inevitable [6][7]. Group 3: Pathways to Stabilize the Real Estate Market - Experts suggest various strategies to address the current challenges in the real estate market, including the potential for easing purchase restrictions in major cities to stimulate market activity, as evidenced by positive trends in cities like Chengdu after policy relaxations [8][9]. - The central government is encouraged to utilize public financial tools to address local fiscal and financial issues, with the issuance of government bonds seen as a viable method to meet market demand for quality assets and support economic recovery [9][10]. - The establishment of a personal bankruptcy protection system is deemed urgent to alleviate the burdens on homeowners unable to continue mortgage payments, which would help protect consumer confidence and overall economic stability [10][11]. Group 4: Importance of Real Estate Stability - The stability of the real estate market is considered more critical than that of the stock market, as it affects a broader segment of the population and directly influences consumer confidence and asset security [11][12]. - The central government is believed to have the capability and experience to address the challenges in the real estate market through institutional innovation and policy tools, which can help restore a healthy market environment [11][12].