Free Speech
Search documents
Disney's Move to Pull 'Kimmel' Sparks First Amendment Debate
Youtube· 2025-09-19 11:01
Core Argument - The article discusses the perceived threats to free speech and the First Amendment under the current administration, highlighting actions taken to control speech by private individuals and companies [2][4][26]. Government Actions - The Trump administration has allegedly used regulatory threats and coercion to influence private companies, compelling them to censor speech that the administration finds objectionable [2][11][24]. - The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) chairman's statements are cited as a direct threat to broadcasters, suggesting that failure to comply with government expectations could lead to regulatory scrutiny [10][11]. Case Examples - The suspension of Jimmy Kimmel's show by Disney is presented as a case where backlash from the administration influenced corporate decisions, raising concerns about the implications for free speech [6][7][10]. - A historical case involving the National Rifle Association (NRA) is referenced, where the Supreme Court ruled that government pressure on private entities to suppress speech violates the First Amendment [18][19]. Legal Implications - There is potential for legal recourse through lawsuits challenging government actions that infringe upon free speech rights, with the possibility of cases reaching the Supreme Court [4][19][26]. - The complexities of such legal actions are acknowledged, particularly regarding the remedies sought and the financial motivations of involved parties [21][26]. Broader Implications - The article raises concerns about the chilling effect on media and public discourse, suggesting that the current environment could deter criticism of the government and undermine the principles of free speech [24][25][26]. - The potential for future administrations to use similar tactics against opposing media is highlighted, emphasizing the risks to free speech across the political spectrum [24][26].
Trump threatens to axe licenses of TV stations that criticize him
BusinessLine· 2025-09-19 06:10
President Donald Trump suggested that US broadcast networks should face scrutiny over their licenses if their content is overwhelmingly critical of him, and defended ABC’s decision to suspend late-night host Jimmy Kimmel’s show indefinitely over remarks about the death of conservative activist Charlie Kirk.“That’s something that should be talked about for licensing, too. When you have a network and you have evening shows, and all they do is hit Trump,” Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One. “They’re lic ...
Trump stokes Kimmel controversy, suggests TV stations could lose their licenses
MSNBC· 2025-09-19 04:23
It is day 242 of the second Trump administration. Tonight, Donald Trump is back in Washington after a state visit to the UK and he returns home to a new firestorm of controversy after ABC pulled late night host Jimmy Kimmel off the air indefinitely. ABC made that decision following criticism from FCC chairman Brendan Carr as well as NextStar, who is a company that operates 28 ABC affiliate stations.And it was all about comments that Kimmel made concerning the suspect in Charlie Kirk's shooting. At least tha ...
‘Canceling comedy’: Oversight Dem likens Trump’s attacks to Red Scare and McCarthy era
MSNBC· 2025-09-19 01:11
Political Strategy & Accountability - The Democratic party is employing oversight and judiciary committees to hold the administration accountable [1][2] - A coordinated approach is being used to issue subpoenas and investigate potential wrongdoings [3][20] - The aim is to expose and hold accountable those carrying out potentially illegal orders, even if higher-ups evade prosecution [16][17] Cancel Culture & Free Speech - The Republican party is accused of engaging in cancel culture by targeting universities, comedians, and private businesses [4] - Concerns are raised about government overreach and the suppression of dissenting voices [10][11] - The FCC is allegedly using its regulatory power to intimidate media companies and stifle free speech [14][15] Political Polarization & Mobilization - The current political climate is compared to historical periods of fear and repression, such as the Palmer Raids and the McCarthy era [10] - There's a call to mobilize the American people to defend the fundamental right to free speech and equality [11] - Democrats are urged to project confidence and leadership in defending democracy and freedoms [21][22]
Hollywood rallies behind Kimmel, while Trump and supporters cheer suspension
NBC News· 2025-09-18 23:31
Tonight, protests outside Disney headquarters as fallout grows from the company's abrupt decision to indefinitely pull Jimmy Kimmel's late night show off the air. Condemnation swift from Democrats in Washington to Hollywood heavyweights. You can't go around firing somebody because you're fearful or trying to suck up to an authoritarian criminal uh administration in the Oval Office.That's just not how this works. But President Trump and many of his supporters praising the decision by ABC and its parent compa ...
‘The first amendment is not what it used to be’: Nicolle Wallace reacts to Jimmy Kimmel’s suspension
MSNBC· 2025-09-18 21:23
Anyone anyone with the profound privilege of sitting in a chair like this one felt something shift over the last 16 hours. Because this afternoon it is abundantly clear to everyone, not just people who sit in chairs like this one, but every single American that the First Amendment in the hands of this current administration isn't what it used to be. It does not protect an individual's right to speak freely.That right endowed by the founders, enshrined in the constitution, fought for, bled for over the cours ...
White House got 'exactly what it wanted' with Kimmel's suspension
NBC News· 2025-09-18 21:01
Welcome to Meet the Press Now. I'm Kristen Welker in Washington where the White House is cracking down on what it deems the radical left and moving to retaliate against some of its most outspoken critics in the wake of the tragic assassination of Charlie Kirk. The White House has publicly called for consequences and firings of anyone whose comments are seen as endorsing Kirk's death. And administration officials are cheering the indefinite suspension of ABC's Jimmy Kimmel in the wake of comments the late ni ...
Jay Leno speaks in support of Jimmy Kimmel: 'Let the people decide'
NBC News· 2025-09-18 20:50
Look, I'm a huge proponent of free speech. Please, I'm I'm on Jimmy Kimber's side of >> Could you have ever imagined something like this happening when you were on here. >> Yeah. Yeah.These kind of things happen all the time, but you know, you don't get cancelled saying popular things. You can cancel, you know, sometimes uh usually it's the truth that winds up getting cancelled. I think Jimmy will land on his feet.He's a talented guy. He's funny. And let's see what happens.I maybe he might be on in just a c ...
'Television media is really vulnerable right now': Journalist on Kimmel removal
MSNBC· 2025-09-18 20:35
FCC Pressure and Media Capitulation - The FCC, under Brendan Carr, is perceived to be exerting pressure on Disney/ABC, potentially influencing content decisions [1][3] - NextStar's merger transaction is a key factor, as they may not want to jeopardize the deal by opposing the FCC [1] - The White House's stance on the issue is unclear, with potential contradictions in Brendan Carr's statements regarding political satire [2][3][4] - A $6 billion deal between NextStar and Tegna is awaiting FCC approval, mirroring a past situation where CBS settled with President Trump for over $16 million before a merger approval [7][8] Free Speech and Legal Considerations - The silencing of Jimmy Kimmel was done by his employer, not the FCC directly, making it an extra-legal issue focused on pressure [1] - Anna Gomez of the FCC stated it is not the FCC's job to judge what is and is not funny, or to determine content [1] - Legal action by Jimmy Kimmel against ABC would depend on his contract terms, specifically termination clauses [1] Media Business Vulnerability - Traditional television media is vulnerable due to declining viewership and advertising revenue [13][16] - News organizations that are part of larger conglomerates may be more susceptible to pressure due to their smaller contribution to the overall balance sheet [15][16] - The media industry is facing a "carrots and sticks" strategy from the White House, leveraging government power to influence media organizations [17] Ownership and Editorial Influence - Media owners are increasingly involved in coverage decisions, dictating terms and influencing editorial posture [18][19] - Examples include Skyance's re-fashioning of CBS News and ownership changes at the Washington Post and Los Angeles Times [20][21]
'Outrageous': Top Oversight Dem will probe ABC's Kimmel decision
MSNBC· 2025-09-18 17:43
We are back with the breaking news. Democrats are launching an investigation after Jimmy Kimmel's show was pulled off the air following his comments about Charlie Kirk. The top Democrat on the House Oversight Committee announced they'll look into the Trump administration, ABC and Sinclair, and what he calls ongoing efforts to censor opposition to the president of the United States.And joining us now, in fact, is the ranking member of the House Oversight Committee, our friend, Congressman Robert Garcia of Ca ...