Core Viewpoint - Shanghai is implementing a gentle approach to outdoor smoking control in popular tourist areas, focusing on persuasion rather than penalties, which has been positively received by the public [1][2]. Group 1: Smoking Control Measures - The initiative targets eight crowded tourist landmarks, aiming to reduce "游烟" (smoking while walking) through a non-confrontational approach [1]. - A survey conducted by Shanghai's health office in 2024 revealed that nearly 60% of residents frequently encounter "游烟," and over 90% express discontent with it [1]. - The city's efforts to expand smoking control to outdoor areas signal a commitment to creating a smoke-free environment [1]. Group 2: Challenges in Implementation - The dispersed nature of "游烟" presents significant challenges for effective monitoring and enforcement, increasing supervision costs and difficulties [2]. - Current regulations lack clear definitions and enforcement mechanisms for outdoor smoking, leading to potential gaps in compliance and effectiveness [2][3]. - The absence of stringent national smoking laws hampers the ability to impose penalties for indoor smoking, complicating outdoor smoking control efforts [2][3]. Group 3: Legislative Needs - Experts have called for accelerated national legislation on smoking control to provide a robust legal framework for enforcement [3]. - The lack of clear legal guidelines has resulted in ambiguous situations, as seen in a recent incident at Shanghai Disneyland where a dispute arose over smoking [3].