Summary of Selective Insurance Group Conference Call Company Overview - **Company**: Selective Insurance Group (NYSE: SGZ.CL) - **Event**: 2026 Conference on February 10, 2026 - **Key Speakers**: CEO John Marchioni and CFO Patrick Brennan Core Industry Insights - **Historical Performance**: Selective Insurance has a long history of stability and growth, celebrating its 100th anniversary in 2026. The company has averaged over 12% Return on Equity (ROE) over the past decade [4][11] - **Recent Challenges**: The last two years have seen volatility due to reserving actions related to General Liability and Commercial Auto Liability lines, which are longer-tailed lines of business [5][6] - **Emerging Trends**: The company is addressing trends such as lawsuit abuse and social inflation, which are impacting severity trends in casualty lines. The overall severity trend is reported at about 9% for casualty lines, and closer to 10% when excluding workers' compensation [17][21] Financial Performance and Strategy - **ROE Performance**: The company reported a 14.2-point operating ROE in the past year, maintaining a long-term track record of producing over 12 points of ROE [11] - **Reserving Strategy**: The goal is to maintain stability in reserves, ensuring that the most recent years are booked accurately to support future profitability [9][10] - **Combined Ratio Guidance**: The underlying accident year combined ratio for 2025 is projected to improve by about 120 basis points, with a target range of 90.5-91.5 for the combined ratio [33] Market Dynamics - **Geographic Exposure**: New Jersey represents a significant portion of Selective's business, with 30% of personal auto and 15% of commercial auto premiums coming from the state. The state has been identified as having a higher susceptibility to social inflation due to its legal environment [24][25] - **Litigation Trends**: The litigation rates in New Jersey are about twice the national average for commercial auto, indicating a challenging environment for claims [28] Future Outlook - **Diversification Strategy**: The company aims to diversify its portfolio by expanding into new geographic areas and segments, including personal lines targeting the mass affluent market and increasing its presence in Excess and Surplus lines [35][37] - **Investment in Technology**: Selective has significantly increased its technology budget to enhance capabilities and improve data utilization for pricing and loss cost management [14] Key Takeaways - **Market Positioning**: Selective Insurance is positioned to take advantage of market trends by reacting quickly to emerging data and trends, ensuring that its reserving practices are sound and reflective of current conditions [20][22] - **Shareholder Returns**: The company has returned approximately $100 million to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases, indicating a commitment to returning capital while investing in growth [56][57] Additional Considerations - **Communication with Agents**: The company emphasizes open communication with agents regarding pricing strategies, which is crucial in a competitive market where accounts can easily be shifted to competitors [42][45] - **Public Policy Advocacy**: There is a need for the insurance industry to better communicate the impact of excessive litigation on costs, which could influence public policy and regulatory changes [41]