Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the contrasting evaluations of the streaming series "All Her Fault" between Chinese and Western audiences, highlighting the differences in cultural context and the depth of critique regarding gender roles and societal structures in the narratives of the show compared to previous series like "The Good Wife" and "Shameless" [1][38]. Group 1: Comparison of Series - "All Her Fault" and "The Good Wife" both depict elite male figures named Peter in Chicago, showcasing the evolution of fatherhood and marriage perceptions over two decades [4][10]. - "The Good Wife" presents a transactional marriage where both partners rely on each other for personal and professional gains, despite Peter's flaws [6][22]. - In contrast, "All Her Fault" critiques the performative aspects of masculinity, revealing how the male character's protective nature is a guise for control and exploitation [7][9]. Group 2: Gender and Class Dynamics - "All Her Fault" portrays motherhood as a zero-sum game, where societal expectations place the burden of caregiving primarily on women, leading to a struggle between career and family [9][39]. - The series addresses class disparities by featuring characters from various socioeconomic backgrounds, yet fails to deeply explore how these differences shape their identities and experiences [28][31]. - The portrayal of disability in "All Her Fault" is superficial, lacking the depth seen in "Shameless," which intricately weaves class and health issues into character development [30][34]. Group 3: Ideological Critique - "All Her Fault" offers a more radical critique of patriarchal structures compared to "The Good Wife," reflecting a shift in societal attitudes towards marriage and gender roles over the past two decades [10][38]. - The writing in "All Her Fault" is criticized for being lazy and overly reliant on tropes, which undermines the complexity of its characters and narratives [11][38]. - The differences in audience reception between China and the West can be attributed to varying cultural contexts, with the former resonating more with the show's themes of motherhood and female solidarity due to historical neglect of these issues [41][42].