Lemonade rating: 3 out of 5 stars Lemonade pet insurance stands out for its great prices. If you’re looking for a rather bare-bones pet insurance policy at a good price, check out Lemonade’s pricing for your pet. Lemonade sells additional coverage as add-ons for extra cost, so you’ll pay more if you want a pet insurance policy comparable to many competitors, which include broader coverage in their base plans. Learn more: How does pet insurance work? A complete guide. Lemonade pet insurance pros and ...