BABA(US:BABA) Guan Cha Zhe Wang·2025-05-26 03:19Core Viewpoint - The release of "Three Kingdoms Fantasy Continent 2: Song of the Heroes" has faced a rapid decline in reputation within a week, despite a strong initial performance on the iOS free game chart [1][3]. Performance Summary - "Song of the Heroes" debuted at the top of the iOS free game chart but fell to 36th place by May 23, and briefly entered the Top 10 of the revenue chart before dropping out of the top 20 [3][5]. - The game's rating on TapTap plummeted to 5.3, with a significant number of one-star reviews, indicating a poor reception among players [3]. Comparison with Predecessor - The predecessor, "Three Kingdoms Fantasy Continent," launched in 2020 and consistently ranked in the top 10, ultimately generating over 10 billion in revenue, establishing itself as a phenomenon in the card game genre [5]. - In contrast, "Song of the Heroes" has struggled to maintain a competitive position, being compared unfavorably to lesser-known games [5]. Artistic and Gameplay Changes - The project team acknowledged the importance of art style in attracting players, noting that the original game's aesthetic successfully drew in a diverse user base [6]. - The sequel has undergone significant changes in art style, moving away from the previous aesthetic that appealed to many players, which may alienate existing fans while attempting to attract new ones [10][12]. Narrative and User Experience - The narrative approach in "Song of the Heroes" has been criticized for lacking depth and failing to engage players, with a focus on a "camera-like" character perspective that diminishes player involvement [10][12]. - The storyline has been described as superficial, with the game failing to effectively utilize the Three Kingdoms backdrop, leading to dissatisfaction among players [12]. Company Background and Future Outlook - Lingxi Interactive Entertainment, a subsidiary of Alibaba, has seen mixed results in its gaming ventures, with internal criticisms regarding its cultural alignment with Alibaba's broader goals [16][18]. - The company aims to become the third-largest game company in China within eight years, but the poor reception of "Song of the Heroes" poses significant challenges to achieving this goal [18].