OpenAI路线遭质疑，Meta研究员：根本无法构建超级智能

Core Insights - The pursuit of "superintelligence" represents a significant ambition among leading AI companies like Meta, OpenAI, and Google DeepMind, with substantial investments being made in this direction [1][3][4] - Sam Altman of OpenAI suggests that building superintelligence is primarily an engineering challenge, indicating a belief in a feasible path to achieve it [3][4] - Meta AI researcher Jack Morris argues that the current approach of using large language models (LLMs) and reinforcement learning (RL) may not be sufficient to construct superintelligence [1][2] Group 1: Current Approaches and Challenges - Morris outlines three potential methods for building superintelligence: purely supervised learning (SL), RL from human validators, and RL from automated validators [2] - The integration of non-text data into models is believed not to enhance overall performance, as human-written text carries intrinsic value that sensory inputs do not [2][6] - The concept of a "data wall" or "token crisis" is emerging, where the availability of text data for training LLMs is becoming a concern, leading to extensive efforts to scrape and transcribe data from various sources [8][19] Group 2: Learning Algorithms and Their Implications - The two primary learning methods identified for potential superintelligence are SL and RL, with SL being more stable and efficient for initial training [10][22] - The hypothesis that superintelligence could emerge from SL alone is challenged by the limitations of current models, which may not exhibit human-level general intelligence despite excelling in specific tasks [15][16] - The combination of SL and RL is proposed as a more viable path, leveraging human feedback or automated systems to refine model outputs [20][22][28] Group 3: Future Directions and Speculations - The potential for RL to effectively transfer learning across various tasks remains uncertain, raising questions about the scalability of this approach to achieve superintelligence [34] - The competitive landscape among AI companies is likely to intensify as they seek to develop the most effective training environments for LLMs, potentially leading to breakthroughs in superintelligence [34]