Workflow
First Amendment
icon
Search documents
X @Tesla Owners Silicon Valley
"I think we should be extremely concerned about anything that undermines the First Amendment. There is a reason for the 1st Amendment. People came from countries where they could not speak freely where saying certain things would get you thrown in prison."Elon Musk https://t.co/MQchANL4cB ...
'Lies': Fox News paints L.A. as war zone while protests remain largely peaceful
MSNBC· 2025-06-12 00:35
Political Commentary & Social Issues - The report highlights widespread mobilization against perceived overreach by Donald Trump's administration, including actions against peaceful demonstrators and communities [1][2] - The report emphasizes the constitutional right to protest and frames such actions as a positive response to perceived authoritarian threats [3] - The report criticizes the double standard in pardoning January 6th rioters while condemning current protests, accusing the administration of misrepresenting peaceful demonstrations [5][6][8] - The report suggests that Donald Trump's actions, including federalizing the National Guard, aim to suppress dissent and reflect a disregard for law and order [9] - The report contrasts the administration's portrayal of protests with the reality of largely peaceful demonstrations, accusing media outlets like Fox News of exaggerating violence [11][12][13] - The report draws parallels between current protests and historical movements like the Civil Rights Movement and anti-Vietnam War protests, emphasizing the importance of nonviolent direct action [16][17][18] - The report cites a Quinnipiac poll indicating Donald Trump is "underwater" by 11 points on immigration and down 16 points on deportations, suggesting public opposition is gaining traction [23] Historical Context & Legal Analysis - The report references the Boston Tea Party and the Civil Rights Movement as examples of effective protest in American history [16] - The report highlights a judge's ruling against the detention or deportation of a student for protected free speech during campus protests [24] Media & Public Perception - The report accuses the White House of disseminating propaganda and selectively editing footage to misrepresent the scale and nature of protests [12]
Trump threatens would-be protesters of his birthday military parade
MSNBC· 2025-06-11 02:08
And today, amidst all this, he is explicitly threatening protesters at his birthday parade. Not lutters, not rioters, nor vandals, nor lawb breakakers. No, just protesters.And we're going to be celebrating big on Saturday. We're going to have a lot of And if there's any protester wants to come out, they will be met with very big force. By the way, for those people that want to protest, they're going to be met with very big force.And I haven't even heard about a protest, but you know, this is uh people that ...
California AG sues Trump over 'unlawful' National Guard order
MSNBC· 2025-06-10 11:02
Protests and Civil Unrest - Protests continued in downtown Los Angeles, with fewer clashes reported compared to the weekend, focusing on the Trump administration's immigration raids [1] - The deployment of 2,000 additional National Guard troops brought the total to 4,700, alongside activated Marines, which California's Governor deemed unnecessary and potentially illegal [2] - Local officials reported looting and graffiti in downtown LA, with investigations and potential arrests to follow [7] - Protests, while mostly peaceful, experienced escalation attempts by some individuals, leading to police intervention [8][9] - Mayor Karen Bass pleaded with the federal government to halt ICE raids, highlighting the impact on Los Angeles' diverse community [10] Government and Military Response - The Trump administration deployed National Guard troops and Marines, a move defended by the President despite criticism [2][3][4] - The National Guard's primary mission is to support civilian authorities, such as guarding federal buildings [18][19][13] - Concerns were raised about the appropriateness and training of Marines for civil unrest situations, particularly regarding interaction with civilians [19][20][21] - The potential invocation of the Insurrection Act was mentioned as a dangerous escalation point [22] - Coordination between military personnel, federal agencies (ICE, FBI), and local police (LAPD) is crucial to avoid confusion and escalation [26][27][28]
The Beat With Ari Melber - June 9 | Audio Only
MSNBC· 2025-06-10 01:09
Political and Legal Analysis - The Trump administration's deployment of the National Guard and Marines in Los Angeles, without the California governor's consent, marks a significant escalation with little modern precedent, potentially testing the limits of presidential power [1][2][4][5][8] - California is suing the president, arguing he overstepped his authority by invoking war powers to send in troops, claiming there is no actual invasion or rebellion, but rather constitutionally protected protests [8][9] - Legal experts suggest the administration's actions may be unlawful, as they lack a clear legal basis and could be a pretextual misuse of emergency powers, potentially violating the Posse Comitatus Act [25][26][31][54][57] - Critics argue the administration's actions are a "test run" to expand presidential authority and suppress dissent, potentially leading to more aggressive responses to protests in the future [5][32][34][50] - The administration's actions are seen as an attempt to normalize a type of enforcement not seen in the country for a long time, using military tactics and gear against peaceful protesters [83][84] Immigration Enforcement and Community Impact - Federal immigration agents conducted widescale enforcement actions in Los Angeles, targeting day laborers, many of whom are undocumented but not violent offenders [17][18][19] - Community members and leaders expressed alarm and opposition to the presence of immigration officers, viewing it as a raid on hardworking communities [21][22] - The deployment of troops is seen as unnecessary, as local law enforcement is capable of handling the protests and demonstrations [7][79] - There are concerns that the administration's actions are creating chaos and confusion, leading to the arrest of individuals attending immigration hearings [53] Strategic Response and Historical Context - Experts suggest that protesters should strategically avoid confronting the National Guard and Marines, as the administration seeks to create images of chaos and justify further military intervention [88][89][90] - The situation is compared to autocratic moments in history, with the administration potentially using the National Guard as "bait" to provoke a response and expand its power [85][86] - The deployment of troops is contrasted with historical instances where federal intervention was necessary to protect civil rights, arguing that the current actions infringe on those rights [4][28][78]
Troops in the streets! Ari Melber on Trump courting legal showdown in L.A.
MSNBC· 2025-06-10 00:45
Legal & Constitutional Concerns - The President's deployment of National Guard troops in LA is testing the bounds of the law, potentially exceeding presidential authority established over half a century ago [1] - The President invoked a statute to deploy the National Guard without collaborating with the state governor, a move that could be challenged in court [2] - The US code requires an invasion, rebellion, or inability to enforce laws through regular forces to justify such action, and the President's claim that protests constitute a "rebellion" lacks legal support [3][19][20] - Legal experts note the statute doesn't authorize using federal troops in the way the President intends, and no president has done this without state governor permission since the civil rights movement [5] - California is challenging the President's actions in court, arguing infringement on California's legal rule and federalism [9] Political & Strategic Implications - The President's actions are seen as a test case for deploying troops in other cities in response to protests [14] - The President's actions may be an attempt to divert attention from other challenges, such as unfulfilled promises regarding the economy, wars, and tariffs [27][28] - The administration's legal strategy involves invoking emergency powers and obscure laws to address non-emergency situations, a problematic trend for democracy [24][26] Factual Disputes & Evidence - There is a dispute over whether the administration coordinated with the governor before deploying the National Guard [10][11] - The governor claims there was no coordination and accuses the President of lying, while the President's aids suggest otherwise [10][11]