Workflow
相邻权侵权
icon
Search documents
商铺遭施工被封堵三年,“闲置”期间物业费由谁承担?法院判了!
Yang Zi Wan Bao Wang· 2025-10-22 12:59
Core Viewpoint - The court case highlights the responsibility of developers for infringing on the rights of property owners due to construction activities, establishing a legal precedent for similar disputes [1][3]. Group 1: Case Background - In 2018, property owners purchased a commercial unit but faced road blockage due to adjacent construction, rendering the unit unusable until mid-2022 [2]. - The property management company demanded payment of 6,891 yuan in property fees for the period when the unit was unusable, leading the owners to file a lawsuit after paying the fees [2]. Group 2: Court Ruling - The court found that the developer was responsible for the road blockage and ruled that the property owners were entitled to compensation for property fees paid during the blockage period, amounting to 5,964 yuan [3]. - The ruling clarified that while the property management company acted within legal bounds by collecting fees, the developer's actions constituted an infringement of the owners' rights [3]. Group 3: Legal Insights - The presiding judge emphasized the importance of distinguishing between different legal relationships, stating that the developer must bear the consequences of their actions while the property management company is entitled to fees as per the service contract [5]. - The judge advised construction companies to consider the impact of their activities on neighboring properties and to take reasonable measures to minimize disruption [5].