Core Viewpoint - The film "Dongji Island" fails to accurately portray the revolutionary spirit and the people's struggles during wartime, leading to a disconnect with audiences and poor reception [1][4][20]. Box Office Performance - Despite a strong promotional campaign and the context of the 80th anniversary of the victory in the War of Resistance, "Dongji Island" experienced a high opening but quickly declined in box office performance, with a total of 1.80 billion yuan after three days of release [2][3]. Comparison with Other Films - "Dongji Island" is contrasted with "Nanjing Photo Studio," which is praised for its quality and depth, highlighting the failure of "Dongji Island" to reflect the true essence of the people and the revolution [5][24]. Characterization and Themes - The film presents a distorted view of the people as uncivilized and ignorant, while the protagonists are depicted as almost divine figures, which undermines the historical context and the role of the masses in the revolution [6][10][20]. - The narrative structure and character development are criticized for lacking depth and failing to resonate with the audience, resulting in a film that feels disjointed and superficial [13][22]. Historical Representation - The film's portrayal of the people's struggles during the war is seen as overly simplistic and fails to honor their contributions, instead framing them as needing enlightenment from the protagonists [19][21]. - The disconnect between the film's narrative and the actual historical experiences of the people leads to a lack of authenticity and emotional engagement [22][24].