Tax Rate
Search documents
I Asked ChatGPT What Would Happen If Billionaires Paid Taxes at the Same Rate as the Average California Resident
Yahoo Finance· 2025-10-12 14:12
Core Viewpoint - The discussion around billionaire taxes centers on the potential impact of taxing the ultra-wealthy at the same effective rate as average citizens, with various interpretations of what "tax rate" means [1][2]. Tax Rate Definitions - The term "tax rate" can be interpreted in three main ways, each leading to different revenue outcomes [3]. - The first interpretation focuses on effective federal income tax rates, where average U.S. filers pay approximately 14% to 15% of their income in federal taxes, representing a conservative estimate [3]. - The second interpretation considers the total tax burden, which includes federal, state, payroll, local, property, and sales taxes, with typical households paying around 27% of their income in combined taxes [4]. - The third interpretation treats the tax as a wealth tax, where billionaires would pay the same percentage of their total wealth annually as average individuals pay of their income [4]. Revenue Scenarios - ChatGPT analyzed three scenarios to estimate potential revenue from taxing billionaires [5]. Scenario 1: Matching Federal Income Tax Rates - If billionaires paid the same effective federal income tax rate as average Americans (around 14% to 15%), it could generate tens of billions annually, but this approach has limitations due to much of billionaire wealth growth being from unrealized capital gains [6][7]. Scenario 2: Matching Total Tax Burden - This scenario would require billionaires to pay about 27% of their economic income in combined taxes, similar to typical households, potentially raising hundreds of billions annually and significantly reducing income inequality [8]. - Implementing this would necessitate major changes in capital income taxation, including closing avoidance strategies and possibly introducing new tax mechanisms [8].