Core Viewpoint - The controversy revolves around the alleged imitation of the "Golden Crab" design by jewelry designer Wu Wensheng, with claims that the original model was created by Junqing Studio, leading to widespread online discussion [1][4]. Group 1: Originality Claims - Junqing Studio claims that the "crab model" in question is their "Chinese Velvet Crab Model," which was part of their "Five Insects Record" series, initiated by designer Hua Qian [4]. - The studio asserts that they have documentation of the design process from inception to sale, emphasizing their originality [4]. - The model was first publicly showcased on June 9, 2023, with some modeling files dating back to October 2022 [4]. Group 2: Copyright Dispute - Wu Wensheng argues that the copyright registration of Junqing Studio is based on simulated grayscale images, while his "Golden Crab" is registered as a physical object, indicating a difference in copyright categories [5][6]. - Wu maintains that both parties' copyrights do not conflict, stating that he respects legitimate intellectual property rights [6]. - The studio's copyright certificate indicates that the "Chinese Velvet Crab" was completed and first published on February 17, 2024 [4]. Group 3: Market Response - Following the controversy, Sam's Club temporarily removed the disputed product from sale and is conducting a thorough investigation with suppliers [6]. - Initial checks revealed that while both products are themed as "golden crabs," they differ in design details, internal structure, and surface craftsmanship [6].

Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding the "Golden Hairy Crab" model sold at Sam's Club has raised significant attention regarding intellectual property rights and potential infringement claims [1][12]. Group 1: Background of the Controversy - Jewelry designer and intangible cultural heritage inheritor Wu Wensheng accused Sam's Club of selling a model that closely resembles his original "Golden Hairy Crab" design, which he claims took nearly two years to create [1]. - The model was launched at the Zhangjiagang Sam's Club on October 20, 2023, leading to public discussions on social media about the originality of the design [1]. Group 2: Responses from Involved Parties - Wu Wensheng expressed an open attitude towards the controversy, emphasizing that his previous statements about removing counterfeit products were aimed at protecting his intellectual property rights rather than targeting any specific entity [12]. - The designer from "Junqing Studio," known as Er Liu, stated that their "Chinese Velvet Crab" model was the original design, with records of its creation dating back to October 2022 [5][11]. Group 3: Details of the Design and Production Process - The design process for the crab model involved purchasing crabs for research, creating models on a computer, and then 3D printing for testing before sale [5]. - The studio's model was officially available for sale starting in early 2024, with initial design records and public displays occurring in mid-2023 [5][9]. Group 4: Legal and Regulatory Actions - Following the allegations, Wu Wensheng reported the issue to local authorities, and the Zhangjiagang municipal government confirmed that the copyright bureau is investigating the matter [14]. - Sam's Club has temporarily removed the product from sale and is conducting a thorough review of the supplier's materials to address the infringement claims [14].