Workflow
科学期刊
icon
Search documents
论文工厂产业化、AI代写成风 科学出版业面临学术诚信危机
Ke Ji Ri Bao· 2025-08-11 23:59
Core Viewpoint - The rise of scientific fraud, exacerbated by the emergence of generative AI technologies, has created a complex industry chain that poses unprecedented challenges to the scientific publishing sector [1][4]. Group 1: Scientific Fraud Industry - A significant investigation focused on the journal "Public Library of Science: ONE" revealed that 33 editors had an unusually high rate of retracted or criticized papers, with one editor handling 79 papers, 49 of which were retracted, amounting to a 62% retraction rate [2]. - The investigation also identified organized bulk publishing of questionable papers, with over 2,000 papers flagged for duplicate images on the peer review platform PubPeer, often published simultaneously in a limited number of journals [2]. - The Academic Research and Development Association (ARDA) in Chennai, India, exemplifies this industry by offering one-stop services for paper writing and journal publication, charging between $250 and $500 [3]. Group 2: Impact of AI on Research Integrity - Since the launch of ChatGPT in 2022, the proportion of AI-generated content in scientific papers has been steadily increasing, with approximately 22.5% of computer science paper abstracts identified as modified by large language models [4]. - A 2023 study indicated that one-third of researchers could not identify AI-generated medical journal abstracts, highlighting concerns about the reliability of AI-generated content [4]. - The integration of AI technologies has made fraudulent practices more covert, complicating the efforts to maintain research integrity [5]. Group 3: Addressing Academic Fraud - The academic community is actively seeking solutions to combat the evolving landscape of academic fraud, with initiatives to investigate the presence of paper mills and enhance research integrity [5][6]. - Experts emphasize the need to shift the evaluation system in academia away from an overemphasis on the quantity of published papers, advocating for increased focus on research reproducibility and the quality of peer reviews [6]. - Establishing stricter standards for AI usage in research, such as requiring authors to disclose AI involvement in their papers, is deemed essential for maintaining academic integrity [6].