Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the controversies surrounding Wangzai Xiao Qiao, including a significant loss of followers and backlash over concert plans and copyright issues, indicating potential long-term damage to the artist's reputation and fanbase [1][3]. Group 1: Follower Loss and Controversy - Wangzai Xiao Qiao has lost over 3 million followers since July 19, with the rate of loss accelerating, suggesting ongoing negative public sentiment [1]. - The planned masked concert on August 9 in Shanghai, with ticket prices ranging from 268 to 968 yuan, has faced criticism for being a cash grab due to the artist's decision to not reveal her face and primarily perform cover songs [3]. Group 2: Copyright Dispute - Wangzai Xiao Qiao's insistence that the original singer of "Nianlun" is only Zhang Bicheng, while denying contributions from Wang Sulong, has angered Wang Sulong's fans and led to a breakdown in their long-term collaboration [3]. - Following the controversy, Wang Sulong's team announced the withdrawal of the song's authorization, while Zhang Bicheng's studio stated they would no longer perform the song despite holding permanent performance rights [3]. Group 3: Concert Postponement and Apology - On July 26, the concert was postponed, and ticket refunds were initiated, indicating a significant operational setback for Wangzai Xiao Qiao [4]. - An apology letter released by Wangzai Xiao Qiao failed to address key criticisms such as lip-syncing and copyright issues, instead vaguely stating acceptance of criticism [4]. Group 4: Public Reaction to Apology - The apology was criticized as insincere and formulaic, with netizens mocking it as lacking genuine effort and sincerity [5]. - Influencer Liu Jiushou expressed frustration over the apology, suggesting that true accountability requires a detailed acknowledgment of mistakes and a commitment to change [6].