Appian
Search documents
Appian Strengthens Leadership Team with Key Hires in UK and EMEA
Prnewswire· 2025-07-02 13:35
Core Insights - Appian is expanding its sales leadership team to enhance its market presence and drive growth in the UK, Europe, the Middle East, and Africa (EMEA) [1] - The new appointments include Vicky Nesbit as SVP of Sales UK and EMEA, Vincent Perrin as VP of EMEA North, and Rob Cook as VP of EMEA North for Broad Markets and Public Sector [1][2][3][4] - The strategic hires are aimed at leveraging their extensive experience to innovate and deploy AI and process orchestration for organizational success [2] Company Overview - Appian has been providing a software platform for over 25 years, helping organizations improve processes, reduce costs, and enhance customer experiences [5][6] - The company serves many of the world's largest companies across various industries, emphasizing its commitment to client success [6]
Raft and Appian Announce Strategic Partnership to Address Indo-Pacific Readiness
Prnewswire· 2025-06-10 13:00
Core Insights - Raft and Appian have formed a strategic partnership to enhance logistics and warfighting data integration for U.S. military forces in the Indo-Pacific region [1][2] - The collaboration aims to address critical operational challenges in sustaining distributed forces, particularly in the context of strategic competition with China [2][3] - The solution integrates fragmented supply chain and operational data, enabling faster and more informed decision-making [3][4] Company Overview - Raft specializes in autonomous data fusion and Agentic AI, providing advanced solutions to the Department of Defense and national security organizations [5] - The company is trusted by over 25 federal agencies, including the U.S. Air Force and U.S. Space Force, to modernize operations and enhance decision-making capabilities [4][5] - Appian delivers a software platform focused on process orchestration, helping organizations improve operational efficiency and gain a strategic edge [6]
成立六个月,DOGE究竟做出了什么成绩?
Hua Er Jie Jian Wen· 2025-05-14 07:57
DOGE成立半年,声称节省1700亿美元,实际可验证数字远低于此。 根据英国《金融时报》近日的调查,DOGE不仅未能实现最初承诺的削减金额,就连其网站宣称已节省 的1700亿美元也有严重水分。这些数字中只有很小一部分可以被验证。 自由市场智库Cato Institute的分析师Dominik Lett表示: "DOGE声称的节省金额很可能远低于马斯克最初的目标。DOGE不应被视为非常成功的赤字 削减努力。" 1700亿美元?夸大的合同节省! 去年,马斯克在纽约麦迪逊广场花园的特朗普集会上曾宣称要削减近三分之一的联邦年度预算,数额高 达2万亿美元。但后来将目标缩减到了1万亿美元。他解释称,设定更高的目标是为了争取更好的结果, 即使最终实现1万亿美元的削减,也已经是一个"史诗般的成果"。 然而,到了今年4月,马斯克在白宫内阁会议上进一步宣布,预计在2026财年只能节省约1500亿美元。 如今,这一系列承诺已成为马斯克的沉重负担。 摩根士丹利的Michael Cembalest本月表示: "虽然DOGE确实揭示了一些浪费性支出,但它在可验证的削减方面过度承诺而交付不足。" 尽管取得了部分成功,但DOGE长期隐忧 随 ...
Appian(APPN) - 2025 Q1 - Quarterly Report
2025-05-08 17:16
PART I [PART I. FINANCIAL INFORMATION](index=4&type=section&id=PART%20I.%20FINANCIAL%20INFORMATION) This section presents Appian's unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements and management's discussion and analysis for the quarter ended March 31, 2025 [Financial Statements](index=4&type=section&id=Item%201.%20Financial%20Statements) This section presents Appian's unaudited condensed consolidated financial statements for the quarter ended March 31, 2025, highlighting a significant reduction in net loss and an 11.1% increase in total revenue [Consolidated Balance Sheets](index=4&type=section&id=Consolidated%20Balance%20Sheets) As of March 31, 2025, Appian reported total assets of $592.9 million, a decrease from $621.0 million at year-end 2024, with cash and cash equivalents increasing to $135.0 million Consolidated Balance Sheet Highlights (in thousands) | Account | March 31, 2025 | December 31, 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | **Assets** | | | | Cash and cash equivalents | $134,982 | $118,552 | | Total current assets | $411,902 | $435,543 | | Total assets | $592,899 | $621,039 | | **Liabilities and Stockholders' Deficit** | | | | Deferred revenue, current | $258,582 | $281,760 | | Total current liabilities | $330,382 | $354,756 | | Total liabilities | $624,644 | $653,679 | | Total stockholders' deficit | $(31,745) | $(32,640) | [Consolidated Statements of Operations](index=5&type=section&id=Consolidated%20Statements%20of%20Operations) For the three months ended March 31, 2025, Appian's total revenue grew 11.1% year-over-year to $166.4 million, significantly narrowing its operating loss to $(0.8) million Quarterly Statement of Operations (in thousands, except per share data) | Metric | Q1 2025 | Q1 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Subscriptions Revenue | $134,352 | $117,694 | | Total Revenue | $166,426 | $149,835 | | Gross Profit | $127,508 | $111,838 | | Operating Loss | $(834) | $(19,535) | | Net Loss | $(1,177) | $(32,923) | | Net Loss Per Share (Basic & Diluted) | $(0.02) | $(0.45) | [Consolidated Statements of Cash Flows](index=8&type=section&id=Consolidated%20Statements%20of%20Cash%20Flows) For the first quarter of 2025, net cash provided by operating activities significantly increased to $45.0 million, with cash and cash equivalents at period-end reaching $135.0 million Quarterly Cash Flow Summary (in thousands) | Activity | Q1 2025 | Q1 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Net cash provided by operating activities | $44,966 | $18,866 | | Net cash (used by) provided by investing activities | $(24,077) | $7,459 | | Net cash used by financing activities | $(5,509) | $(4,249) | | Net increase in cash and cash equivalents | $16,430 | $20,757 | | Cash and cash equivalents at end of period | $134,982 | $170,108 | [Notes to Condensed Consolidated Financial Statements](index=9&type=section&id=Notes%20to%20Condensed%20Consolidated%20Financial%20Statements) This section provides detailed accounting policies and disclosures, including revenue recognition, debt, and the status of the Pegasystems litigation Revenue Breakdown (in thousands) | Revenue Source | Q1 2025 | Q1 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Cloud subscriptions | $99,826 | $86,603 | | Term license subscriptions | $26,914 | $23,771 | | Total subscriptions | $134,352 | $117,694 | | Professional services | $32,074 | $32,141 | | **Total revenue** | **$166,426** | **$149,835** | - As of March 31, 2025, the company had an aggregate of **$519.1 million** in transaction price allocated to unsatisfied performance obligations, with **$331.9 million** expected to be recognized as revenue over the next 12 months[57](index=57&type=chunk) - The Supreme Court of Virginia granted Appian's petition to hear its appeal regarding the **$2.036 billion** judgment against Pegasystems, which was previously reversed by a lower court[86](index=86&type=chunk) - The company has a non-cancellable cloud hosting arrangement with AWS with minimum annual spending requirements of **$44.0 million** from November 2024 to October 2029[82](index=82&type=chunk) [Management's Discussion and Analysis of Financial Condition and Results of Operations](index=25&type=section&id=Item%202.%20Management's%20Discussion%20and%20Analysis%20of%20Financial%20Condition%20and%20Results%20of%20Operations) Management discusses the company's financial performance, highlighting revenue growth, cost changes, and significant improvements in operating loss and adjusted EBITDA for Q1 2025 [Overview and Strategy](index=25&type=section&id=Overview%20and%20Strategy) Appian positions itself as 'The Process Company,' leveraging AI-integrated software to enhance business processes and grow through strategic partnerships - Appian's platform unifies capabilities like Process Orchestration, Data Fabric, Process Intelligence, and Artificial Intelligence to enable enterprise transformation[105](index=105&type=chunk)[109](index=109&type=chunk) - The company intends to increasingly rely on strategic partners for professional services, which is expected to cause professional services revenue as a percentage of total revenue to decline over time[110](index=110&type=chunk) [Key Metrics](index=28&type=section&id=Key%20Metrics) The company monitors key metrics, including cloud subscriptions revenue, which grew 15.3% to $99.8 million, and the cloud subscriptions revenue retention rate, which was 112% Cloud Subscriptions Revenue (in thousands) | Period | 2025 | 2024 | % Change | | :--- | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Three Months Ended March 31 | $99,826 | $86,603 | 15.3% | Cloud Subscriptions Revenue Retention Rate | As of March 31, | 2025 | 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | Rate | 112% | 120% | [Results of Operations Comparison (Q1 2025 vs Q1 2024)](index=33&type=section&id=Results%20of%20Operations%20Comparison) Comparing Q1 2025 to Q1 2024, total revenue increased by 11.1% to $166.4 million, driven by subscriptions revenue growth and a 3.6% decrease in operating expenses - Total revenue increased by **$16.6 million** (11.1%), with subscriptions revenue up **$16.7 million**, driven by both new and existing customers[144](index=144&type=chunk) - Sales and marketing expense decreased by **$3.6 million** (6.2%), mainly due to a **24% reduction in headcount** from March 2024 to March 2025[148](index=148&type=chunk) - General and administrative expense increased by **$0.8 million** (2.5%), driven by higher IT spending and professional fees, partially offset by lower insurance and personnel costs[150](index=150&type=chunk) - Other income was **$5.7 million**, a significant shift from an **$8.2 million expense** in the prior year, primarily due to foreign exchange gains versus prior-year losses[151](index=151&type=chunk) [Non-GAAP Financial Measures](index=36&type=section&id=Non-GAAP%20Financial%20Measures) Appian uses non-GAAP measures, reporting a non-GAAP operating income of $14.3 million and adjusted EBITDA of $16.8 million for Q1 2025, a strong improvement year-over-year Reconciliation of GAAP Net Loss to Adjusted EBITDA (in thousands) | Line Item | Q1 2025 | Q1 2024 | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | GAAP net loss | $(1,177) | $(32,923) | | Adjustments (Other income, Interest, Taxes, D&A, etc.) | $17,936 | $17,747 | | Stock-based compensation expense | $10,039 | $10,606 | | Litigation Expense & JPI Amortization | $4,796 | $5,246 | | **Adjusted EBITDA** | **$16,759** | **$(1,322)** | [Liquidity and Capital Resources](index=39&type=section&id=Liquidity%20and%20Capital%20Resources) As of March 31, 2025, Appian had $135.0 million in cash and cash equivalents, with sufficient liquidity to support operations for at least the next twelve months - The company believes existing cash, investments, and cash flows from operations will be sufficient to support working capital and capital expenditures for at least the next 12 months[163](index=163&type=chunk) - In Q1 2024, the company repurchased **1.3 million shares** for approximately **$50.0 million** under its share repurchase program[91](index=91&type=chunk)[170](index=170&type=chunk) - Net cash from operating activities increased to **$45.0 million** in Q1 2025 from **$18.9 million** in Q1 2024, driven by strong cash collections and cost management[175](index=175&type=chunk) [Quantitative and Qualitative Disclosures About Market Risk](index=43&type=section&id=Item%203.%20Quantitative%20and%20Qualitative%20Disclosures%20About%20Market%20Risk) The company is exposed to market risks from interest rates, inflation, and foreign currency exchange rates, with potential impacts on interest expense and total revenue - A hypothetical **1% increase** in interest rates on the company's **$248.0 million** debt would increase annual interest expense by about **$2.5 million**[182](index=182&type=chunk) - A **10% adverse change** in foreign currency exchange rates during Q1 2025 would have negatively impacted total revenue by approximately **$6.0 million**[184](index=184&type=chunk) - The company does not currently engage in hedging for foreign currency transactions but may do so in the future[185](index=185&type=chunk) [Controls and Procedures](index=43&type=section&id=Item%204.%20Controls%20and%20Procedures) Management concluded that the company's disclosure controls and procedures were effective as of March 31, 2025, with no material changes in internal control over financial reporting during the quarter - The CEO and CFO concluded that as of March 31, 2025, the company's disclosure controls and procedures were effective at the reasonable assurance level[188](index=188&type=chunk) - No changes in internal control over financial reporting occurred during the quarter that have materially affected, or are reasonably likely to materially affect, these controls[189](index=189&type=chunk) PART II [PART II. OTHER INFORMATION](index=45&type=section&id=PART%20II.%20OTHER%20INFORMATION) This section provides additional information including legal proceedings, risk factors, equity security sales, and exhibits [Legal Proceedings](index=45&type=section&id=Item%201.%20Legal%20Proceedings) This section refers to Note 12 of the financial statements for information regarding the ongoing litigation with Pegasystems, noting no other material adverse legal proceedings - For details on legal proceedings, the report refers to Note 12, which discusses the Pegasystems litigation[192](index=192&type=chunk) [Risk Factors](index=45&type=section&id=Item%201A.%20Risk%20Factors) The company states that there have been no material changes from the risk factors previously described in its Annual Report on Form 10-K for the year ended December 31, 2024 - There have been no material changes from the risk factors described in the company's 2024 Annual Report on Form 10-K[194](index=194&type=chunk) [Unregistered Sales of Equity Securities and Use of Proceeds](index=45&type=section&id=Item%202.%20Unregistered%20Sales%20of%20Equity%20Securities%20and%20Use%20of%20Proceeds) This section details the company's purchases of its own equity securities, with 17,259 shares purchased in Q1 2025 under the ESPP Issuer Purchases of Equity Securities (Q1 2025) | Month | Total Shares Purchased | Average Price Paid per Share | | :--- | :--- | :--- | | January 2025 | 5,232 | $34.85 | | February 2025 | 5,678 | $35.18 | | March 2025 | 6,349 | $31.24 | | **Total** | **17,259** | **$33.63** | [Exhibits](index=47&type=section&id=Item%206.%20Exhibits) This section lists the exhibits filed with the Form 10-Q, including certifications by the Principal Executive Officer and Principal Financial Officer, and XBRL data files - The exhibits include CEO and CFO certifications pursuant to Sarbanes-Oxley Sections 302 and 906, as well as Inline XBRL documents[201](index=201&type=chunk)
Appian(APPN) - 2025 Q1 - Earnings Call Transcript
2025-05-08 13:32
Financial Data and Key Metrics Changes - In Q1 2025, Appian's cloud subscription revenue grew 15% year over year to $99.8 million, while total revenue increased 11% year over year to $166.4 million [5][31] - Adjusted EBITDA was $16.8 million, a significant improvement from an adjusted EBITDA loss of $1.3 million in the same period last year [35] - Non-GAAP net income was $9.8 million or $0.13 per diluted share, compared to a non-GAAP net loss of $4.9 million or $0.07 per share for Q1 2024 [35] Business Line Data and Key Metrics Changes - Cloud subscriptions revenue represented 81% of total revenue, up from 79% in the year-ago period [32] - Professional services revenue was $32.1 million, flat compared to Q1 2024, with expectations for a long-term decline as a percentage of total revenue [32] Market Data and Key Metrics Changes - International operations contributed 36% of total revenue, down from 37% in the year-ago period [33] - Federal government bookings grew 59% year over year, indicating strong performance in the public sector [21][110] Company Strategy and Development Direction - The company is focusing on AI integration within its processes, emphasizing practical applications over hype [6][10] - Appian aims to transition away from per-seat pricing models to alternative pricing mechanisms that reflect AI's value [83] - The introduction of a multi-tiered pricing model for AI features has resulted in revenue from AI-inclusive tiers more than doubling in Q1 [12] Management's Comments on Operating Environment and Future Outlook - Management remains cautiously optimistic about the federal government's spending patterns and overall business momentum despite macroeconomic uncertainties [39][48] - The company has not seen material changes in its sales pipeline, indicating stability in its business operations [39] Other Important Information - Appian's weighted rule of 40 score is 27, combining growth and margin metrics [27] - The company plans to report on new internal metrics to provide better visibility into its performance [28] Q&A Session Summary Question: About government performance and potential pull forward into Q1 - Management does not believe pull forwards were a meaningful factor in Q1 and remains cautiously optimistic about Q3 [46][48] Question: Regarding cloud net retention rates and spending hesitation - Management noted that the net retention rate is a trailing metric and attributed the dip to unrelated down sells and leveling off of revenue growth from some customers [49][50] Question: On AI and the new agentic world - Management emphasized the importance of practical results from AI applications and the need for structured processes to support AI deployment [56][60] Question: Incremental monetization from AI usage - Management is pleased with customer willingness to spend on AI and sees significant value in demonstrating tangible results [65][67] Question: About the new CFO's focus areas - Management expressed excitement about the new CFO's contributions but did not disclose specific strategic details [68][69] Question: On intelligent document processing (IDP) success - Management highlighted the advancements in IDP, which now requires no training on document formats, leading to higher accuracy and customer satisfaction [102][104] Question: Federal government revenue growth compared to expectations - Management indicated that federal revenue growth exceeded expectations, with a year-over-year increase of 21% [110]
Appian (APPN) Surpasses Q1 Earnings and Revenue Estimates
ZACKS· 2025-05-08 13:30
Core Insights - Appian (APPN) reported quarterly earnings of $0.13 per share, exceeding the Zacks Consensus Estimate of $0.03 per share, compared to a loss of $0.24 per share a year ago, indicating a significant earnings surprise of 333.33% [1] - The company achieved revenues of $166.43 million for the quarter ended March 2025, surpassing the Zacks Consensus Estimate by 2.20% and showing an increase from $149.84 million in the same quarter last year [2] - Appian has consistently surpassed consensus EPS estimates over the last four quarters, indicating strong performance [2] Earnings Outlook - The sustainability of Appian's stock price movement will largely depend on management's commentary during the earnings call and future earnings expectations [3][4] - The current consensus EPS estimate for the upcoming quarter is -$0.14 on revenues of $160.09 million, while for the current fiscal year, it is $0.17 on revenues of $676.39 million [7] Industry Context - The Internet - Software industry, to which Appian belongs, is currently ranked in the top 37% of over 250 Zacks industries, suggesting a favorable outlook compared to lower-ranked industries [8] - Empirical research indicates a strong correlation between near-term stock movements and trends in earnings estimate revisions, which can impact Appian's stock performance [5][6]
Appian(APPN) - 2025 Q1 - Earnings Call Transcript
2025-05-08 13:30
Financial Data and Key Metrics Changes - In Q1 2025, Appian's cloud subscription revenue grew 15% year over year to $99.8 million, while total revenue increased 11% year over year to $166.4 million [4][30] - Adjusted EBITDA was $16.8 million, a significant improvement from an adjusted EBITDA loss of $1.3 million in the same quarter last year [34] - Non-GAAP net income was $9.8 million or $0.13 per diluted share, compared to a non-GAAP net loss of $4.9 million or $0.07 per share for Q1 2024 [34] Business Line Data and Key Metrics Changes - Cloud subscriptions revenue represented 81% of total revenue, up from 79% in the year-ago period [31] - Professional services revenue was flat at $32.1 million compared to Q1 2024, with expectations for a long-term decline as a percentage of total revenue [31][32] - The cloud subscription revenue retention rate was 112%, down from 120% a year ago [32] Market Data and Key Metrics Changes - International operations contributed 36% of total revenue, slightly down from 37% in the previous year [32] - Federal government bookings grew 59% year over year, indicating strong performance in the public sector [20][104] Company Strategy and Development Direction - The company is focusing on AI integration within its processes, emphasizing practical applications over hype [5][7] - Appian aims to monetize AI features, with revenue from AI-inclusive tiers more than doubling to $9 million in Q1 [11][62] - The introduction of a multi-tiered pricing model allows for better monetization of AI and exclusive features [10] Management's Comments on Operating Environment and Future Outlook - Management expressed cautious optimism regarding the evolving opportunities in the federal government sector despite macroeconomic uncertainties [20][38] - The company is taking a prudent approach to guidance for the remainder of 2025, with expected cloud subscriptions revenue growth between 14-16% for Q2 [38][39] - Management highlighted the importance of maintaining sales and marketing efficiency, with net new bookings per sales rep rising over 30% compared to the previous year [27][81] Other Important Information - Appian's new Chief Financial Officer, Serge Tanga, is expected to contribute significantly to the company's strategy and financial planning [29] - The company plans to report on a new metric called "weighted rule of 40," which combines growth and margin metrics [26] Q&A Session Summary Question: Was there any pull forward in government performance due to uncertainty around ordering patterns? - Management indicated that pull forwards were not a meaningful factor in Q1 and expressed cautious optimism for Q3 [42][44] Question: What drove the decline in cloud net retention rates? - Management explained that the decline was due to down sells from the previous year and leveling off of revenue growth from some customers [46][48] Question: How does Appian differentiate itself in the AI and agentic space? - Management emphasized the importance of practical applications of AI and the need for structured processes to support AI deployment [52][56] Question: What is the expected contribution from AI in 2025? - Management is optimistic about the willingness of customers to spend on AI and plans to transition away from per seat pricing [78][80] Question: How durable are the recent sales productivity gains? - Management believes the productivity gains are durable and stem from recent innovations and improved sales practices [82][84] Question: What is the impact of narrowing the channel focus on go-to-market efficiency? - Management noted that focusing on trusted partners has significantly expanded the partner-generated pipeline [88][90]
Appian(APPN) - 2025 Q1 - Earnings Call Presentation
2025-05-08 11:38
Financial Performance - Total revenue for Q1 2025 was $1664 million, an 11% increase compared to Q1 2024[10] - Cloud subscriptions revenue reached $998 million in Q1 2025, a 15% growth from Q1 2024[10] - Subscriptions revenue totaled $1344 million in Q1 2025, reflecting a 14% increase year-over-year[10] - Adjusted EBITDA for Q1 2025 was $168 million[7] Margins - Subscriptions gross margin was 89%[10] - Professional services gross margin was 30%[10] - Overall gross margin stood at 78%[10] Customer Retention - Cloud subscriptions revenue retention rate was 112% as of March 31, 2025[8] - Cloud Gross Renewal Rate was 99% in Q1 2025[17] Guidance for Q2 and Full Year 2025 - Q2 2025 cloud subscriptions revenue is projected to be between $1010 million and $1030 million, representing a 14%-16% year-over-year growth[39] - Full year 2025 cloud subscriptions revenue is expected to range from $4190 million to $4230 million, a 14%-15% increase[39] - Full year 2025 total revenue is forecasted to be between $6800 million and $6880 million, indicating a 10%-12% growth[39]
Appian(APPN) - 2025 Q1 - Quarterly Results
2025-05-08 11:10
Exhibit 99.1 Appian Announces First Quarter 2025 Financial Results Cloud subscriptions revenue increased 15% year-over-year to $99.8 million and generated operating cash flow of $45.0 million McLean, VA – May 8, 2025 – Appian (Nasdaq: APPN) today announced financial results for the first quarter ended March 31, 2025. "In Q1, Appian continued to demonstrate our earnings potential, with narrowing net losses, our third straight quarter of positive adjusted EBITDA, and $45 million in operating cash flow," said ...
Appian Announces First Quarter 2025 Financial Results
Globenewswire· 2025-05-08 11:05
Core Insights - Appian reported a 15% year-over-year increase in cloud subscriptions revenue, reaching $99.8 million, and generated operating cash flow of $45.0 million for Q1 2025 [1][4] - The company achieved its third consecutive quarter of positive adjusted EBITDA, indicating improved operational efficiency [1][4] Financial Highlights - Total subscriptions revenue, including cloud and on-premises licenses, rose 14% year-over-year to $134.4 million [4] - Professional services revenue remained flat at $32.1 million compared to Q1 2024 [4] - Total revenue increased by 11% year-over-year to $166.4 million [4] - The cloud subscriptions revenue retention rate was reported at 112% as of March 31, 2025 [4] Operating Performance - GAAP operating loss narrowed to $(0.8) million from $(19.5) million in Q1 2024 [4] - Non-GAAP operating income was $14.3 million, a significant improvement from a non-GAAP operating loss of $(3.7) million in the same quarter last year [4] - GAAP net loss decreased to $(1.2) million from $(32.9) million in Q1 2024, with net loss per share improving to $(0.02) from $(0.45) [4][21] Cash Flow and Investments - Net cash provided by operating activities was $45.0 million for the three months ended March 31, 2025, compared to $18.9 million for the same period in 2024 [4][27] - The company reported an increase in cash and cash equivalents to $134.982 million as of March 31, 2025, up from $118.552 million at the end of 2024 [18][27] Future Guidance - For Q2 2025, cloud subscriptions revenue is expected to be between $101.0 million and $103.0 million, reflecting a year-over-year growth of 14% to 16% [4] - Full-year 2025 guidance anticipates total revenue between $680.0 million and $688.0 million, representing a year-over-year increase of 10% to 12% [10]