Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding the song "Year Ring" highlights the evolving dynamics of copyright and original artist recognition in the music industry, emphasizing the need for clearer contractual agreements to prevent disputes [3][5][6]. Group 1: Background of the Controversy - The song "Year Ring" was originally written and composed by Wang Sulong, with the version sung by Zhang Bichen released on June 15, 2015, and Wang Sulong's version released on June 30, 2015 [1]. - The dispute escalated when internet celebrity "Wang Zai Xiao Qiao" claimed Zhang Bichen as the "only original singer," leading to significant backlash from Wang Sulong's fans and subsequent actions from music platforms [1][2]. Group 2: Industry Implications - The incident reflects a growing awareness and respect for copyright in the music industry, with all parties acknowledging Wang Sulong's core authorship rights [3][4]. - The definition of "original singer" is not legally established, leading to ambiguity that relies on contractual agreements and industry practices [3][4]. - The emphasis on the "original singer" label is crucial in the current music sharing landscape, where covers can significantly enhance the original work's exposure [4]. Group 3: Legal and Contractual Considerations - The dispute underscores the necessity for clear contractual terms regarding "original singer" and "first performance rights" to align rights with legal protections [5][6]. - The resolution of the controversy, which resulted in both parties withdrawing from the song, serves as a cautionary tale for the music industry regarding the importance of well-defined agreements [5][6].