Group 1 - The Supreme People's Court has released a third batch of typical cases related to bride price disputes, aiming to unify the adjudication standards for such cases and respond to new situations and issues in judicial practice [1] - The court clarified that payments for housing and vehicles made with the intention of marriage can be treated according to bride price adjudication rules, considering local customs and the purpose of the payment [2] - A case involving a car payment was highlighted, where the court determined that the payment was made with the intention of marriage, thus qualifying as a bride price, and ordered a partial refund based on various factors [3] Group 2 - The court reiterated its stance against obtaining property through marriage, emphasizing that any party seeking property must return it if the marriage does not occur, and criminal liability may apply in cases of fraud [4] - In assessing bride price disputes, the court will consider not only whether a marriage registration occurred but also the background of the parties, their cohabitation circumstances, and any wrongdoing [4]

Core Viewpoint - The Supreme People's Court of China has clarified that monetary gifts given with the intention of marriage, such as housing and vehicle payments, can be treated as bride price and adjudicated accordingly [1][2][3] Group 1: Case Summary - In a case involving Zhao and Li, Zhao provided a bride price of 66,000 yuan and a vehicle payment of 150,000 yuan, both intended for marriage [1] - The court ruled that both payments were made with the purpose of marriage and thus qualified as bride price, supporting Zhao's request for a refund [1][2] - The court ordered Li to return over 170,000 yuan after considering the actual consumption and circumstances surrounding the relationship [1] Group 2: Legal Framework - The Supreme Court's regulations state that large monetary gifts given with the intent of marriage should be treated as bride price under the applicable rules [3] - The court emphasized that the determination of bride price should consider local customs, the purpose of the payment, and the relationship context [2][3] - The court also clarified that certain small gifts given on special occasions or for emotional expression do not qualify as bride price [5] Group 3: Judicial Attitude - The Supreme Court reiterated its stance against using marriage as a means to extract financial benefits, emphasizing the need for comprehensive evaluation of the relationship context [5] - The court highlighted the importance of marriage registration as a formal requirement in assessing claims related to bride price [5]