Core Viewpoint - The discussion around the new game "Dual Shadow Realm" for Switch 2 has sparked significant debate, particularly regarding the use of a redemption code instead of a physical cartridge, leading to feelings of deception among consumers [1][3]. Group 1: Product Features and Consumer Reactions - The initial batch of "Dual Shadow Realm" includes only a redemption code, which can only be used once and is tied to a Nintendo account, causing frustration among consumers who expected a physical cartridge [3][5]. - Future physical versions will include a "key card," which requires downloading the game but still needs to be inserted to play, combining drawbacks of both digital and physical formats [6][8]. - Some consumers argue that the transition to digital distribution is beneficial for third-party developers, reducing costs and ensuring access to the latest game versions [9][10]. Group 2: Collectibility and Ownership Concerns - The "key card" is seen as a diminished form of ownership, as it represents a mere access key rather than a true collectible, impacting the value for collectors [13][21]. - The trend of digital content replacing physical media raises concerns about the permanence of ownership, as seen in the backlash against the "Death Stranding 2" collector's edition lacking a physical disc [14][30]. - The shift towards digital media has led to a loss of tangible ownership, with consumers often only acquiring "usage rights" rather than true ownership of the content [29][32]. Group 3: Industry Trends and Future Implications - The media landscape is increasingly moving towards online and streaming formats, which, while offering benefits like updates, also pose risks of losing access to content if servers are shut down [24][25]. - The "Stop Killing Games" movement highlights consumer frustration over losing access to purchased games when servers are closed, emphasizing the need for longer service durations from companies [26][31]. - The potential disappearance of physical game cartridges may lead to a future where younger generations are unfamiliar with the concept of physical media, as digital formats become the norm [41][44].