Core Insights - Constellation Brands and Kraft Heinz have both experienced significant stock declines over the past year, with Constellation down over 40% and Kraft Heinz down about 25%, while the S&P 500 rose nearly 20% during the same period [3][9][12] Constellation Brands - Constellation generates most of its revenue from beer, facing challenges from tariffs and declining demand among younger consumers [5][7] - The Trump administration's tariffs on aluminum have increased from 25% to 50%, impacting Constellation's margins as 39% of its beer shipments come in aluminum cans [6] - The company is attempting to adapt by launching new alcoholic beverages and divesting lower-end brands to focus on higher-end products, which may strengthen long-term margins but hinder near-term revenue growth [8] - For fiscal 2026, Constellation expects organic sales to dip 4% to 6% and comparable EPS to drop 16% to 18%, leading to a stock valuation of 12 times forward earnings [9] Kraft Heinz - Kraft Heinz owns a portfolio of well-known brands but has struggled post-merger due to a focus on cost-cutting rather than brand revitalization [10] - The company faced a $15 billion write-down in 2019 and has since recovered by divesting weaker brands and raising prices, but organic net sales dipped 2% in 2024 [11][12] - For 2025, Kraft Heinz expects organic net sales to decline by 1.5% to 3.5% and adjusted EPS to drop 13% to 18%, with the stock trading at 10 times forward earnings [12] - Kraft Heinz plans to split into two companies by the second half of 2026, but concerns remain about whether this will effectively address its challenges [13] Investment Considerations - Both companies face significant challenges that hinder their attractiveness as investments, with a preference for Constellation due to clearer long-term strategies [14][15]

Company Overview - Kraft Heinz will split into two companies, reversing much of the $46 billion merger from a decade ago that created one of the largest food companies globally [1] - The split aims to enhance capital allocation, prioritize initiatives, and drive scale in promising areas, according to Miguel Patricio, executive chair of the board [4] New Company Structure - The first new company will focus on shelf-stable meals, including brands like Heinz, Philadelphia, and Kraft mac and cheese, projected to have $15.4 billion in net sales for 2024, with approximately 75% of sales from sauces, spreads, and seasonings [2] - The second new company will consist of a "scaled portfolio of North America staples," including Oscar Mayer, Kraft singles, and Lunchables, with an estimated $10.4 billion in net sales for 2024 [3] Historical Context - The merger that created Kraft Heinz in 2015 was initiated by Berkshire Hathaway and 3G Capital, initially well-received by investors, but faced challenges as U.S. sales declined [4] - The company faced significant issues, including a subpoena from the SEC regarding accounting policies, a 36% dividend cut, and a $15.4 billion write-down on major brands [5] - Following these challenges, Kraft Heinz underwent leadership changes, additional write-downs, and divestitures of certain business units, including its cheese unit and nuts division [6] Industry Trends - The split aligns with a broader trend in the food industry, where companies are pursuing breakups to divest from slower-growth categories and enhance investor appeal [7] - Other companies, such as Keurig Dr Pepper and Kellogg, have also pursued similar strategies to separate their business units for better performance [7]

Group 1 - The impact of tariffs imposed by the Trump administration is affecting major coffee brands like Kraft Heinz, which has requested suppliers to notify price increases 60 days in advance [1] - Kraft Heinz's coffee business generated net sales of $835 million, accounting for approximately 3% of its total net sales of $25.8 billion in the last fiscal year [2] - The company has raised its cost increase expectations for the year from 3% to 5%, with coffee costs expected to rise significantly due to adverse weather and crop failures, causing raw bean prices to nearly double over the past year [2] Group 2 - The Green Coffee Association's contracts stipulate that tariff costs should be borne by the buyer, indicating a clear understanding of the trade rules among coffee traders [1] - Kraft Heinz is facing challenges in maintaining its market position against private labels and startups, as sales and volumes have significantly declined in the latest quarter [2] - The company is seeking collaboration with suppliers to mitigate the impact of tariffs, highlighting the difficulties U.S. companies face in navigating the unpredictable trade policies [1]