Group 1 - France proposed an unprecedented economic sanction plan on May 14, targeting Russian energy exports and countries purchasing Russian oil, with tariffs potentially reaching 500% on specific energy products [1][3] - The sanctions not only target Russian energy exporters but also extend to importers, creating a "collective punishment" model that could impact the global energy supply chain [3] - The effectiveness of the proposed policy will depend on the cooperation of other EU member states, as unilateral implementation of such high tariffs would violate WTO rules and severely disrupt the stability of the European energy market [3] Group 2 - There are visible cracks in the EU's internal consensus on sanctions against Russia, with multiple countries facing pressure from soaring energy prices [5] - The French government's aggressive proposal may not adequately consider the capacity of member states or the potential chain reactions on the global supply chain [5] - The Macron administration may need to reassess its diplomatic priorities, focusing on domestic industrial challenges and public welfare rather than pursuing extreme sanctions that may be difficult to implement [5]