学术道德

Search documents
IMO怒斥OpenAI自封夺金,“91位评委均未参与评分”,网友:炒作无下限
量子位· 2025-07-21 04:23
Core Viewpoint - OpenAI's announcement of its model's performance at the International Mathematical Olympiad (IMO) has sparked controversy, with many officials and academics criticizing the timing and legitimacy of the claim, suggesting it undermines the focus on the participating youth [1][4][5]. Group 1: OpenAI's Announcement and Reactions - OpenAI claimed to have achieved a "gold medal" in the IMO, but this assertion is contested as they were not one of the AI companies officially collaborating with the IMO, and no official evaluators were involved in assessing their submissions [3][4]. - The IMO organizers expressed that AI companies should wait at least a week after the closing ceremony to announce results, emphasizing the need to prioritize the young participants [6][10]. - OpenAI's representative acknowledged that they did not contact the IMO officials beforehand and only informed one organizer, who requested a delay in the announcement [7][8]. Group 2: Comparison with Other AI Companies - In contrast to OpenAI's bold announcement, Google DeepMind chose to remain restrained, adhering to the IMO's guidelines and waiting for an appropriate time to release their results, despite potentially achieving similar success [12][13]. - DeepMind's adherence to the IMO's request highlights a stark difference in approach compared to OpenAI, raising questions about the ethical considerations in AI competition announcements [12][14]. Group 3: Implications for Academic Integrity - The situation has ignited a debate about academic integrity and commercial hype, with critics labeling OpenAI's actions as "rude and inappropriate" [4][6]. - The IMO's internal scoring guidelines, which are not publicly accessible, further complicate the legitimacy of OpenAI's claimed results, as no external evaluation based on these guidelines was conducted [14][15]. Group 4: IMO Results and Future Events - The Chinese team topped the IMO rankings with a total score of 231 points, achieving six gold medals, while the United States team followed with five golds and one silver [17][18]. - The next IMO will be hosted by Shanghai High School, which has a history of success in the competition, having won 18 gold medals overall [30].