Workflow
过罚不相当
icon
Search documents
无证经营被罚500万?过罚不相当,撤销!成都法院发布“护企”典型案例
Sou Hu Cai Jing· 2025-07-23 18:10
Group 1 - The Chengdu Intermediate People's Court held a meeting focused on addressing administrative legal challenges faced by enterprises, with participation from 13 key companies across various sectors including culture, technology, commerce, and sports [1][3] - A significant administrative penalty case was discussed, where a small mushroom cultivation company faced a fine totaling nearly 5 million yuan for operating without a license. The court later deemed the penalty excessive and revoked it, citing the principle of proportionality [3][4] - The meeting established a closed-loop mechanism for addressing enterprise concerns, allowing for immediate responses to simple issues and a commitment to timely feedback for more complex problems [3][4] Group 2 - Representatives from over ten companies voiced concerns regarding high frequencies of administrative inspections, historical approval obstacles, and difficulties in credit restoration [4] - Suggestions included involving insurance companies as co-defendants in traffic accident disputes and balancing labor rights with corporate autonomy in labor disputes [4] - The meeting aimed to provide stable administrative guidance and government services for private enterprises through legal review of administrative actions [4]