Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the chaotic phenomena associated with the "fan circle" culture, highlighting the negative impacts on both fans and society, and the ongoing efforts to regulate and manage these issues [4][9][12]. Group 1: Fan Circle Culture and Its Impact - The "fan circle" culture has emerged from the flow economy, where fans actively participate in promoting their idols, often leading to emotional investment and community building [7][8]. - Many fans, like a 17-year-old girl named Qianqian, experience both joy and distress from their involvement, often feeling overwhelmed by the negative aspects such as online conflicts and emotional turmoil [5][6]. - Extreme behaviors from fans, including public disturbances and online harassment, have raised concerns about public order and the influence on youth [7][10]. Group 2: Regulatory Challenges - Despite previous regulatory efforts, issues like illegal fundraising and online conflicts persist, often resurfacing through new platforms and methods [11][12]. - The lack of effective regulation stems from the strong organizational capabilities of fan groups, which are not recognized as formal market entities, complicating oversight by tax and business authorities [12][13]. - Commercial entities, including MCN organizations, contribute to the chaos by manipulating fan emotions for profit, necessitating stricter controls [15][16]. Group 3: Solutions and Recommendations - A multi-faceted approach is needed to address the "fan circle" issues, involving not just fans and celebrities but also regulatory bodies and educational institutions [16][17]. - Recommendations include identifying and regulating fan organizations, promoting awareness of the issues, and providing guidance to youth to foster a healthier environment [17][18]. - Specific measures proposed for online platforms include banning artist rankings, regulating fan group accounts, and preventing the incitement of fan conflicts [18][19].