Core Viewpoint - The competition between top Douyin streamers, Dong Yuhui and Crazy Xiao Yang, has reached a conclusion, with Dong Yuhui emerging as the leading figure in 2024, while Crazy Xiao Yang faces significant setbacks due to controversies and regulatory issues [4][36]. Group 1: Background and Development - Dong Yuhui achieved a single-day sales record of 176 million yuan during the 618 shopping festival, while Crazy Xiao Yang has been absent from the live streaming scene for nine months due to a scandal involving false advertising [4][6]. - The contrasting growth trajectories of the two streamers highlight their different backgrounds: Dong Yuhui, educated and from a teaching background, focuses on cultural value in his streams, while Crazy Xiao Yang, a grassroots figure, gained fame through comedic content [7][9]. - Both streamers initially rose to prominence on Douyin, with Crazy Xiao Yang becoming the first streamer to surpass 100 million followers on a single platform in November 2022 [10][11]. Group 2: Market Position and Audience - The audience demographics for the two streamers differ significantly: Crazy Xiao Yang appeals primarily to younger, lower-tier market consumers, while Dong Yuhui targets middle-class viewers [19]. - The user structure reflects a cultural divide, with Crazy Xiao Yang's audience comprising 75% from the younger generation and urban blue-collar workers, whereas Dong Yuhui's audience includes 60% from white-collar professionals and affluent mothers [19]. Group 3: Controversies and Challenges - Crazy Xiao Yang faced a major setback due to a scandal involving false advertising related to a mooncake product, leading to regulatory investigations and a suspension of his streaming activities [22][35]. - Despite the challenges, Crazy Xiao Yang's company, San Zhi Yang, reported a GMV of 16 billion yuan in 2023, with a 97% year-on-year growth in the first five months of 2024 [22]. Group 4: Strategic Approaches - Dong Yuhui emphasizes a philosophy of rational consumption and aims to contribute to cultural and agricultural initiatives, distancing himself from the typical influencer model [27][29]. - In contrast, Crazy Xiao Yang continues to operate under his established "crazy" persona, which has been both a strength and a liability as the industry moves towards more regulated practices [20][22]. Group 5: Future Prospects - Dong Yuhui has expanded his business ventures into various sectors, including cultural programs and tourism, and has established multiple companies to diversify his income streams [37]. - Crazy Xiao Yang's new app, "Xiao Yang Zhen Xuan," has struggled to gain traction despite his large follower base, indicating potential challenges in re-establishing his brand [39].