Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the pricing controversy surrounding a 2-kilogram bag of ice sold by Sam's Club for 22.8 yuan, highlighting the debate over consumer perception, pricing strategies, and brand positioning in the market [5][6][13]. Pricing Controversy - The ice product, "Farmer Spring Pure Transparent Edible Ice," is priced at 22.8 yuan, which is nearly three times the cost of the water used to make it, raising questions about its value [8][11]. - Comparatively, similar products from other brands, such as a 1 yuan ice cup from Mixue and a 22.89 yuan 3-kilogram product from Metro, highlight the significant price difference [12][13]. - The pricing strategy is justified by the use of deep lake water from Qiandao Lake and a unique 24-32 hour slow freezing process, which is claimed to reduce melting speed by 20% [14][16]. Market Dynamics - Despite the controversy, the ice product has seen high sales, with some stores experiencing temporary shortages, indicating strong consumer demand [23]. - The ice market is projected to grow significantly, with a forecasted market size exceeding 63 billion yuan by 2026, driven by a 39% growth rate in instant retail channels [40]. Brand Strategy - Farmer Spring is not new to the ice market, having previously launched a 160-gram ice cup priced at 4.4 yuan, indicating a strategic move towards premium pricing [27]. - The introduction of the bagged ice product represents an extension from convenience store offerings to family and outdoor consumption, capitalizing on cost control and repurchase potential [30][31]. Consumer Behavior - The target demographic for Sam's Club includes high-spending members who prioritize convenience and quality over price, suggesting a shift in consumer preferences towards premium products [36]. - The article emphasizes that the value of the ice product is ultimately determined by consumer behavior and perception, reflecting broader trends in consumption and lifestyle [57].