代码后稀缺时代

Search documents
Karpathy氛围编程最新指南,三层AI编程结构:顺境Cursor,逆境Claude,绝境GPT-5 Pro
3 6 Ke· 2025-08-26 01:31
Core Insights - The article discusses the new Vibe Coding guide released by Karpathy, which introduces a three-layer structure for AI programming, emphasizing the integration of multiple models rather than focusing on a single one [1][4]. Group 1: Three-Layer Structure - The three layers consist of Cursor for simple code completion and modifications, Claude Code/Codex for larger functional blocks, and GPT-5 Pro for solving complex issues [4][5]. - The structure is based on practical programming experience, categorizing tasks by their complexity and the appropriate model to use [4][12]. Group 2: Model Functions - Cursor handles approximately 75% of common tasks through automatic code completion [9]. - Claude Code/Codex is utilized for rapid prototyping and cross-domain code attempts [5][8]. - GPT-5 Pro is employed for the most challenging bugs and complex abstractions, providing deep documentation support [5][13]. Group 3: Communication with AI Models - Karpathy emphasizes the importance of writing specific code snippets or comments at appropriate project locations to communicate task intentions effectively [7][12]. - This method allows for faster and clearer communication compared to relying solely on textual descriptions [7]. Group 4: Advantages and Disadvantages - The tools are particularly useful in unfamiliar areas, saving developers from repetitive tasks and enabling quick generation of visual or debugging code [11]. - However, there are drawbacks, such as the tendency for AI-generated code to lack elegance and clarity, often requiring manual cleanup by developers [12][13]. Group 5: Community Engagement - The article highlights the importance of sharing experiences and insights within the developer community to foster continuous improvement and iteration of the Vibe Coding concept [13][14]. - Many users resonate with Karpathy's experiences, indicating a shared approach of using AI for minor issues while supervising larger problems [15][17].
Karpathy氛围编程最新指南!三层AI编程结构:顺境Cursor,逆境Claude,绝境GPT-5 Pro
量子位· 2025-08-25 15:47
Core Viewpoint - The article discusses the new Vibe Coding guide released by Karpathy, which introduces a three-layer structure for AI programming that leverages multiple models to enhance coding efficiency and effectiveness [1][3]. Group 1: Three-Layer Structure - The three layers consist of Cursor for auto-completion and minor code modifications, Claude Code/Codex for larger functional blocks, and GPT-5 Pro for solving complex bugs and providing in-depth documentation [4][6]. - This structure is based on Karpathy's practical programming experience, categorizing tools by their usage frequency and task types [5][6]. - The first layer, Cursor, handles about 75% of common tasks through auto-completion [9]. Group 2: Tool Utilization and Limitations - Cursor allows for high-bandwidth communication with large language models by embedding specific code snippets or comments to convey task intentions clearly [11][12]. - Claude Code/Codex is used for implementing larger functions, especially in unfamiliar programming areas, and can generate visual or debugging code quickly [16]. - However, AI-generated code often lacks elegance and may require manual cleanup due to issues like excessive complexity and poor coding style [17][18]. Group 3: Advanced Problem Solving - GPT-5 Pro is utilized for the most challenging problems, effectively identifying bugs after other models fail to do so [20]. - Karpathy emphasizes the importance of community feedback and shared experiences in refining the Vibe Coding concept, which has evolved since its initial introduction [23][22]. Group 4: Community Insights - Users share similar workflows, indicating that small issues are often resolved through AI auto-completion, while larger problems require more oversight and direction [27][29]. - The article highlights the necessity of providing detailed requirements and acceptance criteria to ensure consistency in AI-generated code [31].
马斯克的好兄弟,卡帕西又双叒出新指南,GPT-5 Pro是AI编程最后防线
3 6 Ke· 2025-08-25 04:07
Core Insights - The article discusses the evolving landscape of AI-assisted programming, emphasizing the shift in value from writing code to deleting it in a low-cost code generation environment [1][19] - Andrej Karpathy shares his experiences and methods for maximizing AI's assistance in programming, highlighting the importance of integrating multiple tools for different tasks [2][3] Tool Usage Philosophy - The philosophy of using tools is centered around the idea that tools should serve people, advocating for a combination of various workflows rather than relying on a single "perfect" tool [3] - Different tools excel at different levels of tasks, with tools like Claude Code and Codex being suitable for larger, less complex tasks, while Tab completion requires initial human input [3] Cursor (Tab Auto-Completion) - Karpathy indicates that Tab auto-completion is the primary method used in daily work, accounting for approximately 75% of his coding activities [4] - Writing code blocks or comments in the correct position can effectively communicate task specifications to AI [6] Auxiliary Tools (Claude Code / Codex) - Karpathy notes that while tools like Claude Code and Codex can generate code, they often lack "taste" in coding style, producing overly defensive or complex code [9] - These tools are particularly useful for tasks in unfamiliar areas, such as Rust or SQL, where they can generate extensive code quickly for debugging purposes [9][14] - The concept of the "post-scarcity era" of code is introduced, where the ability to create and discard vast amounts of customized code diminishes the perceived value of code itself [9][19] GPT-5 Pro: The Final Line of Defense - GPT-5 Pro is described as the ultimate tool for addressing the most challenging bugs that other tools cannot resolve, demonstrating its capability to identify subtle issues [14] - It can also assist in optimizing code abstraction and providing high-quality resources for specific topics [14] Characteristics of the Post-Scarcity Era of Code - The programming field is seen as being radically transformed by various paradigms and tools, leading to a sense of urgency to keep up with technological advancements [15] - The article highlights the potential for exploratory and experimental programming due to the lowered barriers to writing code [19]