Core Viewpoint - The ongoing copyright dispute surrounding the song "Year Ring" highlights the complexities and challenges in the music industry's copyright system, particularly in the context of multiple versions and interpretations of songs [1][19][20] Group 1: Background of the Dispute - The controversy began when online singer "Wang Zai Xiao Qiao" claimed that the original singer of "Year Ring" is only Zhang Bichen, leading to a "dual original singer" dispute between the song's creator Wang Sulong and performer Zhang Bichen [3][5] - The year 2015 marked a pivotal moment in China's online music copyright landscape, with the National Copyright Administration issuing a notice to halt unauthorized music distribution, thus ending the "wild west" era of online music [3][4] Group 2: Industry Response - Major music streaming platforms, such as QQ Music and NetEase Cloud, exhibited unusual behavior by altering the "original singer" labels for the song, which raised public skepticism about the criteria for determining "original" status [4][19] - The platforms' actions reflect a lack of a clear and transparent standard for defining "original" in the context of multiple versions of songs, indicating a need for improved governance in the industry [4][20] Group 3: Implications for Copyright System - The "dual original singer" situation underscores the necessity for a more refined and transparent copyright determination system that accommodates the evolving nature of music production and consumption [19][20] - The current copyright framework struggles to adapt to the complexities of multiple interpretations and versions of songs, necessitating a shift towards a more nuanced approach that balances emotional value and commercial interests [20]