Core Viewpoint - The beauty industry is facing a safety crisis due to the detection of the banned substance Sudan Red in various cosmetic products, raising public concern [1] Group 1: Detection of Banned Substance - A third-party testing agency, "Old Dad Testing," reported finding Sudan Red, a chemical dye banned globally since 2003, in multiple cosmetic products [1] - Sudan Red is classified as having genotoxic and potential carcinogenic risks, and it has been listed as a prohibited ingredient in cosmetics by the National Medical Products Administration since 2021 [1] Group 2: Brand Responses - Several brands, including Huaxizi, Tingyan, and Qiyou, have removed the questioned products from their online stores following the allegations [2] - Specific products such as Huaxizi's Peach Fresh Essence Cream and Tingyan's Collagen Essence have been taken down from their official flagship stores [2][8] - Qiyou's Squalane Fragrance Essence is still available but claims that the current stock is a new version, with the problematic batches sent for testing [2] Group 3: Source of Contamination - The source of the banned substance was traced back to a red ingredient containing extracts from Eclipta Prostrata, Melia Azadirachta, and Moringa Oleifera, with a Sudan Red concentration of 1170 ppm [3][4] - The supplier of this ingredient is identified as Campo Research (S) Pte. Ltd, a Singapore-based company specializing in natural plant-based cosmetic ingredients [4][6] Group 4: Industry Implications - The presence of Sudan Red in "natural" ingredients raises questions about the integrity of suppliers, as it was allegedly added to enhance color stability [6][7] - "Old Dad Testing" suggests that the addition of Sudan Red was a deliberate act by the supplier, leaving brands unaware of the contamination [7] Group 5: Ongoing Investigations - Brands are conducting urgent self-checks and sending products for third-party testing to confirm the presence of Sudan Red [11][13] - Some brands, like Kiehl's, have clarified that their current products do not contain the implicated ingredients and comply with national regulations [13]

Core Viewpoint - The beauty industry is facing a safety crisis due to the detection of the banned substance Sudan Red in multiple cosmetic products, raising public concern [1][5]. Group 1: Incident Overview - A third-party testing agency, "Old Dad Testing," reported finding Sudan Red, a chemical dye banned globally since 2003, in various cosmetics [1][5]. - Sudan Red is known for its genotoxicity and potential carcinogenic risks, and it has been listed as a prohibited ingredient in cosmetics by the National Medical Products Administration since 2021 [1][5]. - Several brands, including Huaxizi, Tingyan, and Qiyou, have responded by removing the affected products from their shelves [1][9]. Group 2: Testing and Findings - "Old Dad Testing" discovered that the source of Sudan Red was a red ingredient containing extracts from Eclipta Prostrata, Melia Azadirachta, and Moringa Oleifera, with a Sudan Red content of 1170 ppm [5][7]. - The testing agency conducted public sampling tests on multiple skincare products using the same ingredient, all of which tested positive for Sudan Red [9][10]. - The affected red ingredient was traced back to a Singapore-based supplier, Campo Research (S) Pte. Ltd, which specializes in natural plant-based cosmetic ingredients [5][7]. Group 3: Brand Responses - Brands implicated in the scandal, such as Huaxizi and Tingyan, have initiated product recalls and investigations into their suppliers [9][13]. - Huaxizi's customer service confirmed that they are conducting a strict investigation into the relevant raw material suppliers and have suspended sales of the affected products [9][13]. - Other brands, including Qiyou and Farmacy, are also conducting tests on their products, but some have been less forthcoming about whether their current products contain the problematic ingredients [15][16].

Core Viewpoint - The beauty industry is facing a safety crisis due to the detection of the banned substance Sudan Red in various cosmetic products, raising public concern [1][2]. Group 1: Incident Overview - A third-party testing agency, "Old Dad Testing," reported finding Sudan Red in multiple cosmetic products, which has been banned globally since 2003 due to its genotoxic and potential carcinogenic risks [1][2]. - The National Medical Products Administration of China has included Sudan Red I-IV in its list of banned substances for cosmetics since 2021 [1]. Group 2: Brand Responses - Several brands, including Huaxizi, Tingyan, and Qiyou, have removed the questioned products from their official stores [2][8]. - Huaxizi's Peach Fresh Essence Cream and Tingyan's Collagen Essence have been taken down, while Qiyou's Squalane Fragrance Essence is still available but claimed to be a new version [2][9]. - Brands are conducting investigations and sending products for testing to ensure compliance with safety standards [8][9]. Group 3: Source of Contamination - The source of Sudan Red was traced back to a red ingredient containing extracts from Eclipta Prostrata, Melia Azadirachta, and Moringa Oleifera, with a detected concentration of 1170 ppm [3][4]. - The supplier of this ingredient, Campo Research (S) Pte. Ltd., based in Singapore, has distributors in China [4][5]. Group 4: Industry Implications - The incident highlights the potential for raw material suppliers to intentionally add banned substances under the guise of natural ingredients for coloring purposes [5][6]. - The testing results indicated that multiple products contained Sudan Red IV, with concentrations ranging from 435 to 1982 µg/kg [8].

Core Viewpoint - The article highlights a significant safety issue in the skincare industry, where several brands, including Kiehl's and Huaxizi, have been found to contain the banned substance Sudan Red, raising concerns about product safety and brand risk management [2][11][17]. Group 1: Incident Overview - A third-party testing agency discovered Sudan Red, a banned substance, in a skincare product, with a concentration of 1170 ppm, indicating intentional addition [2][3]. - Multiple skincare products using the same red composite plant ingredient were tested, and all were found to contain Sudan Red [6][11]. - The brands implicated include Kiehl's, Huaxizi, and Farmacy, among others, with consumers expressing concern over the safety of these products [6][11][17]. Group 2: Brand Responses - Kiehl's customer service stated that their products comply with national regulations and may originate from various countries, including the US and France [2][6]. - Huaxizi's customer service claimed that their products have passed inspections by recognized authorities and are registered with the National Medical Products Administration [11][15]. - Both brands emphasized their commitment to product safety, despite the ongoing concerns raised by the testing results [11][15]. Group 3: Industry Implications - The incident underscores the need for brands to enhance their risk assessment capabilities and ingredient sourcing practices to prevent similar occurrences in the future [3][15]. - The article points out that the use of Sudan Red has a history of causing safety crises in various sectors, including food and cosmetics, indicating a broader issue within the industry [11][17]. - The testing agency suggests that many brands may have been misled by suppliers, highlighting the importance of thorough ingredient verification [3][13].

Core Viewpoint - A third-party evaluation agency detected the banned substance Sudan Red in a skin care product, indicating potential human addition due to high levels found in the raw materials used [2][4][10] Group 1: Incident Overview - The substance Sudan Red was found in a skin care product with a concentration of 1170 ppm, significantly exceeding permissible contamination levels [4] - Multiple brands, including Kiehl's and Huaxizi, were implicated as they used the same raw material group containing Sudan Red [6][12] - The incident has raised concerns about the brands' risk identification capabilities and the integrity of their supply chains [2][12] Group 2: Brand Responses - Kiehl's stated that their products comply with national laws and regulations, and the products sold through their official channels are safe [7] - Huaxizi confirmed that their products have passed inspections by recognized authorities and are registered with the National Medical Products Administration [9] - Both brands emphasized their commitment to consumer safety and the integrity of their products [7][9] Group 3: Industry Implications - The incident highlights the need for brands to establish more robust risk assessment systems and improve their ability to identify risky raw materials [3][12] - The involvement of a specific raw material supplier, Campo Research, raises questions about the sourcing and quality control practices within the industry [13] - The historical context of Sudan Red's misuse in various products underscores ongoing challenges in ensuring consumer safety [10][15]