Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's concert highlights ongoing issues in the music industry regarding copyright protection and the legality of cover songs [2][3][25]. Group 1: Concert Details and Controversy - Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's concert was scheduled for August 9 in Shanghai, with nearly 23 million followers online [1]. - The concert faced backlash due to high ticket prices, lack of original content, and a significant portion of the setlist being cover songs, leading to a postponement and over 3 million lost followers [2][5]. - The concert was set to feature 30 songs, including 7 original songs and 15 covers [9]. Group 2: Copyright Issues - The event underscores the challenges of copyright protection in the music industry, with legal experts analyzing the legitimacy of cover songs and the associated costs of rights management [3][14]. - Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's rise to fame was largely due to her covers of popular songs, raising questions about the ownership of rights for these performances [4][25]. - Legal definitions of original, original performer, and cover artist are complex, with the necessity of obtaining authorization from copyright holders for covers [17][23]. Group 3: Legal Perspectives on Cover Songs - Cover artists must secure authorization from copyright holders to avoid infringement, and unauthorized performances for profit are considered illegal [27][30]. - The concept of "fair use" may apply in certain contexts, but high-profile artists like Wang Zai Xiao Qiao are less likely to qualify under this exception due to their commercial success [30][31]. - The legal landscape for copyright enforcement is complicated, with many artists facing challenges in proving infringement due to difficulties in evidence collection [31][39]. Group 4: Financial Implications of Copyright Management - The cost of obtaining rights for cover songs can be substantial, with estimates for Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's concert ranging from 800,000 to 1,000,000 yuan [42][44]. - The fees for popular songs can exceed 50,000 yuan per song, with additional costs for management and legal services [44][45]. - The lack of a standardized system for copyright management complicates the process for artists, particularly those with less financial backing [46][47]. Group 5: Recommendations for Copyright Protection - Artists are advised to take proactive measures to protect their rights, including obtaining time-stamped evidence of their work and formal agreements for rights transfer [52][53]. - The establishment of clearer and more accessible copyright registration systems is necessary to facilitate better management and protection of music rights [47][48].

Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding the masked concert of internet celebrity "Wang Zai Xiao Qiao" has escalated into a public dispute between two major Chinese singers, leading to significant backlash and a drop in her follower count [1][10]. Group 1: Event Background - The incident began with Wang Zai Xiao Qiao announcing a "masked" concert in Shanghai on July 18, 2023, to celebrate her five-year anniversary, which raised questions about the authenticity of her performance [2][8]. - The concert ticket prices ranged from 268 yuan to 968 yuan, comparable to established artists, despite the performance being primarily composed of covers rather than original songs [9][14]. Group 2: Public Reaction and Consequences - Following the announcement, Wang Zai Xiao Qiao faced severe criticism, resulting in a loss of 4.24 million followers across social media platforms, with her accounts being restricted [1][10]. - The controversy intensified as her previous controversial statements were revisited, particularly her claim regarding the original singer of the song "Nian Lun," which further fueled the public debate [10][11]. Group 3: Industry Implications - The incident reflects a broader trend in the industry where internet celebrities are increasingly attempting to monetize their popularity through live performances, despite lacking the necessary vocal skills for such events [17]. - The market for internet celebrity concerts may undergo a "bubble-popping" phase, where only those with genuine talent and dedication to their craft will succeed, pushing the industry towards a more professional and sustainable model [17][18].

Core Viewpoint - The controversy surrounding the masked concert of internet celebrity singer Wang Zai Xiao Qiao highlights the changing dynamics of the concert market, revealing a lack of sincerity and authenticity in the current entertainment landscape [3][4][10]. Group 1: Market Reaction and Fan Trust - Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's concert ticket pricing strategy has faced strong criticism, particularly the high price of 968 yuan for inner tickets, raising questions about the value offered to fans [4][5]. - Following the announcement of the concert, Wang Zai Xiao Qiao's follower count on Douyin dropped from 23.448 million to 18.352 million, a loss of over 5.09 million fans, indicating a direct market response to the controversy [4][10]. - The lack of original content in her performance, with only 7 out of 30 songs being original works, has led to public ridicule, suggesting that fans feel shortchanged [4][14]. Group 2: Comparison with Other Performers - In contrast, comedian Yue Yunpeng's concert sold out quickly despite a higher ticket price of 1580 yuan, demonstrating that sincerity and audience engagement can lead to success even without traditional singing credentials [6][13]. - Yue Yunpeng's performance was characterized by genuine interaction and humor, which resonated with the audience, showcasing that the value of a concert extends beyond just musical talent [7][13]. - The stark difference in audience reception between Wang Zai Xiao Qiao and Yue Yunpeng illustrates the market's intolerance for perceived insincerity and the importance of authentic engagement [7][10]. Group 3: Evolving Concert Market Dynamics - The concert market is shifting towards a more rational and mature phase, where audience expectations for value and authenticity are increasing [15][16]. - The essence of concerts is evolving into a complex exchange of artistic expression and commercial value, where audience trust and engagement are paramount [16][17]. - Future concert success will depend on performers' ability to understand and respect the rules of value exchange, regardless of their public persona [17].